Everything posted by Silent Hunter UK
-
Surge Into the Barents Fourms are open
A great AAR. The VicConds actually require the Soviets to have both boomers survive to win- losing one is an instant loss.
-
Covert-81
The Brno Extraction 0414 Central European Summer Time, Gdynia, Poland In January 1918, the then US President Woodrow Wilson made a speech in which he laid the key points that should be a part of any treaty that ended the then in-progress First World War. One of those points was that Poland should be recreated as an independent state, it then being partitioned among Germany, Russia and Austria-Hungary, with- this is the key part- access to the sea. Part of the Baltic coast of what was then Germany was given to Poland- the “Polish corridor” that separated East Prussia from the rest of Germany, but there was no port there. The one-time Hanseatic League port of Danzig was the nearest suitable port, but its majority German population meant it was placed under the control of the League of Nations rather than given to Poland. The new state wanted a port it fully controlled and so built one at Gdynia, which became the main base of the Polish navy. The Yalta Accords of 1945 handed half of East Prussia to Poland (the USSR getting the rest), along with Danzig, which was renamed Gdansk, a process which involved a large, not exactly voluntary, population shift of Germans to the much smaller Germany and Poles from the half of Poland incorporated into the USSR. Both ports began to thrive. Gdansk would play its role in history with the Solidarity movement, but that is not our concern at the present time. Our story continues in Gdynia, where one man’s espionage career was about to come to an end... *** When your front door goes flying across the living room, it is generally not a good thing. The fact that made it worse was the presence of six soldiers armed with Kalashnikov assault rifles and a man in a trench coat who looked severely annoyed. The soldiers fanned out and quickly found their target. He was lying in his bed, with an air of resignation in his eyes. The trench coat wearing man walked over to him. “Karol Czartoryski?” “You’re SB?” the man responded in Polish, refering to the Polish secret police organisation, “It was inevitable. My actions would have got your attention sooner or later”. “Quite”, the man responded, “We have evidence that you passed information vital to the Polish national security to a capitalist power. You are under arrest for treason against the People’s Republic of Poland”. “Surely that should be Polish Soviet Socialist Republic, comrade? For all our supposed independence, we’re really just a puppet state of Russia” Karol replied, “Yes; I passed on information about the new corvette class to the Americans. No, I don’t deny it. No, I’m not giving up the rest of my network. Not even if you torture me”. “We shall see about that, citizen”, the secret policeman replied, “We will round up your network”. “No, you won’t. I sent the burn code two hours ago, when I saw your agents outside. Even I don’t know their locations now”. “Get up, traitor”. The man did so. He was not going to resist this guy- he did not want him to have a clear conscience on this matter. “I have one thing to say to you- Poland lives”. The use of the slogan of the Polish Home Army, which had resisted the Germans very well during World War Two and been let down by their supposed allies in Moscow during the Warsaw Uprising of 1994, infuriated the officer, but he did not show it. Instead, he called his headquarters and notified them of the arrest- as well as the use of the burn code, the warning that Karol had sent to his network to warn them that they’d been blown. The message was noted at KGB Headquarters in Moscow- a place that had no scruples about tapping internal communications among its “allies”- being logged at 0615 Moscow Summer Time. The duty officer passed it up to his section chief. The section chief passed it up to the Director of the Eighth Chief Directorate, responsible for communications tapping. The Director decided that this was a matter important enough to pass directly to Yuri Andropov, head of the KGB himself. Andropov contacted one of his Deputy Chairmen, Nikolai Arkanov at 0744 Moscow Time, telling him that he needed Chameleon. Arkanov called a woman named Yekaterina Ivanovna Kuznetsova, told her to gather her team and send them to Brno, a town in Czechoslovakia. For Anna Zamoyska, the next few days were not exactly going to be pleasant. 0004 Eastern Daylight Time, Langley, Virginia, USA When a Polish naval officer had walked into the flat of the CIA station chief in Warsaw, the man realised that the ARTICHOKE network had just ceased to exist. He called Langley on a secure line. The duty officer deemed it important enough to ring Mark Gerard, Deputy Director of Operations, at his home address. He’d been up playing the Mattel Intellvision he’d bought recently for his son’s birthday. “Sir”, the officer said, “ARTICHOKE has been blown. We need to get OMELETTE out of the frying pan before she ends up black and crispy. Unfortunately, she’s not at her usual location”. Gerard inwardly groaned at the use of a bad metaphor. “Where is she?” he asked. “Brno. City in Czechoslovakia. Conference of top Eastern Bloc generals”. “Got it. I know just the person to do that”. Gerard made a telephone call to a woman named Dr. Anna Hamilton-Smith. He told her what needed doing. One by one, the members of her team were telephoned and told to report to their headquarters in Brightwood, Washington DC, ASAP, with an overnight bag, as they would be travelling. Section 91 was on a mission into hostile territory.
-
Surge Into the Barents Fourms are open
I think it's best to ask the Umpire about this.
-
Covert-81
Well, one of the characters in this is now attending a meeting in Brno, where Section 91 are trying to rescue a defector. Who has just been shot by a KGB agent. This is just the first post of the RP, which I put here as an example of related fiction. If you want to see more, you could sign up to the site at AJJE Games.
-
Covert-81
Going very strong and always looking for players.
-
Surge Into the Barents Fourms are open
Thanks. I aim to please. When I'm not just aiming...
-
Surge Into the Barents Fourms are open
I'll post it here. Surge Into The Barents AAR Why you should not rile cute people, animals or objects. Especially if they're Ka-25 helicopters. Introduction In warfare, it's just as often the loser making a mistake than the victor getting it right that swings a battle. Hitler lost the Battle of Britain partly because he switched to city raids. The F-117 lost over Kosovo was shot down because of NATO's mistakes more than Serbia's tactics. So it was here. At the premature ENDEX, NATO had lost two of its submarines without getting a single hit on Soviet forces. Both submarines were lost after exposing their position through their own action. That is telling. I will give my perspective on this game, seeing where my views were correct from the other player's forum. The Dictionary Definition of a Tall Order Before STARTEX, the enormity of the challenge that both sides faced was clear to me. We had to stop four very quiet, heavily armed submarines from getting into the two bastions and getting out again. The only advantage the PLARBs had was damage resistance. Having played Dangerous Waters, I have a good idea about how had that was going to be. They, however, had to get all four submarines back home alive to win. I felt we'd probably find a NATO sub more by luck than judgement. I calculated it would take about eight hours for a NATO sub to get to the minefield. Conscious of that fact and that any reinforcement aircraft were basically half an hour away from being able to do anything, I decided to have a system where I would only have about a third of my aircraft up at any one time, with another third ready to scramble in the event of an emergency. I'd been reading Admiral Sandy Woodward's One Hundred Days where he talks about the ASW exclusion zones that were used during the Falklands War. No British sub was allowed in them, so any sub contact had to be hostile. I suggested we use these on our side, marking everything west of the Grisha starting area as an exclusion zone. We allowed the Victor III time to get clear of that area. We also derived an ELF warning system, flashing a message to any subs that they were either in great danger, or a bastion had been breached. My plan in general was to conduct a broad area sweep of the non-bastion area (focussing on the start line initially) using passive search sonobuoys, using my active ones to localise any contacts, determine if they were real, then deal with them appropriately. The passive ones were spaced to cover the area as I only had a limited number of buoys to reload with. I planned to use my Mi-14s in hunter-killer pairs, as per Soviet doctrine. Turbulent Times So we start the exercise. I have some of my aircraft already hovering over the airfield ready to fly to the area. I suspect it'll be a while before we find anything. I thought NATO would find us before we found them. While the surface players had decided to radiate all their radars anyway to get a better chance if an SSM launch took place anyway, I suspected they'd get a firing solution first. I wasn't expecting a radar contact (Turbulent's periscope) at game start. I wasn't expecting it to keep up for a full 19 minutes. My initial thoughts went from "This has to be a diversion" to "This is a GM error" (we'd detected a diesel sub snorkel and he'd mixed the bearings up) to "this guy can't be that stupid" and later to "must be an amateur". Still en route to the battle area, we thought this might be a decoy and I suggested radioing it. Then I suggested an SS-N-14 launch, which the ASW group went for. The Silex was launched at 0515.5, released its torpedo at 0517 and sunk the sub at 0519.5. I couldn't believe we actually got a hit on the submarine and destroyed it, getting at least a draw from that. I'm not going to gloat over this. Miguel Ramon is clearly new at this game and made a mistake he won't make again. We all have moments like this in our early days. Boston Torpedo Party One of my biggest concerns pre-battle was a Harpoon SSM attack on the ASW Group or the Grisha boys (as I called them in my head). I had no concerns about the safety of my Air Group, as the NATO SSNs had no AAW capability. However, things did not look so rosy for the surface fleet. Looking through the annexes, it was clear that the anti-missile capability of these vessels was limited. Most ships carried only the SA-N-4 Gecko, a naval version of the SA-8 SAM, a short range system which would probably get only one chance to take out the advanced seaskimmers. The best vessel was the Kresta, but its SA-N-3 Goblet missiles can't be used against seaskimmers. If the Harpoons flew, which I suspected they would, somebody was going to take some damage. One lunchtime before the 0536 turn I was sitting and thinking whether I, as a NATO player, would launch Harpoon missiles against the Soviet surface forces, in particular a bearing-only-launch at the beginning. I decided against it on the ground that I'd give my position away for no guarantee of severe damage to the Soviet forces. I wasn't even aware of Boston launching two torpedoes at 0533, or Pittsburgh's MOSS launch. No-one else on our side appears to have been either, clearly indicating it failed. I never even got a detection on Pittsburgh, who declined to launch Harpoons at 0536, due to the presence of a Krivak nearly on top of him. The first thing I knew of their presence was at 0536, when three Harpoons burst out of the ocean. I notice that the NATO players planned to launch if they heard someone else launch on the ASW Group. Personally, I'd have launched BOL at the same time for maximum surprise. More Harpoons the better. Talking to Tony, they expected to be detected and decided to attack on their terms and when Brains was about to be "run over" by the ASW Group, Brad launched and Tony followed. When those blasted out, I screamed to Leningradskii (the Kresta), "Get fire control radars on now! Engage that missile!" More calmly, I told the Ka-25 to head to the launch area to find the sub. The Ka-25 took a little while to find Boston. I initially decided not to join it with a May as I felt the Ka-25 could handle it, but when asked again, I sent one over. It then dropped its torpedo, followed by another Silex- the cruiser had eight of the things on board. Both hit their target, destroying Tony's submarine. We had just scored a possible Strategic Victory. I stated IC that the Ka-25 and the crew of Leningradskii would be recommended fo the order of Lenin. I didn't know the precise details of the engagement, only the ASW Group shooting down one, then the other two. It appears it took 12 missiles to do that- with some just making sure. That would have been an issue in a protracted campaign, that's for sure... That said, a massive achievement and my congratulations to Otto for it. Tony's a very experienced player and we can feel justifiablly pleased at sinking him. Failing To Locate Providence I sent one of my Mays over to deal with Brad's launch. I got a MAD contact at 0559, had it flashed to the rest of my side and made my biggest mistake. Having not read the relevant rules, I thought the MAD was a general location indicator and not good enough for an air-dropped torpedo launch. I dropped some buoys in the area, got some faint contacts, but never got another MAD find. This was annoying when I found out, because I felt I'd let the side down. IC, I didn't want to admit I'd lost him. This is the USSR after all... I thought that the NATO submarines, judging by their previous positions, were in four 10nm exclusion bands and sent the Bear to take a look at the band that hadn't been covered. Turned out I was right- I might have found Pittsburgh had the game continued.. I ordered the Hazes to conduct a dipping sonar search at a point I thought the NATO sub might be and go in an expanded circle, along with the May. I also ordered another to be launched to provide reinforcements. The fact the Umpire told me he wanted half an hour's worth of orders made that the best solution. Before the two Hazes could arrive, ENDEX was announced. Back on the Beach- Conclusions We did well in the time we had, but we never found the fourth submarine. Brains (or Brad) could have gotten into one of our bastions and wreaked havoc. I feel that NATO could have gone quiet for much of the journey. They had no rush in all this. Torpedoes could have been used, but the Harpoons were counter-productive. Lessons learned: 1. Read the rules! 2. Never underestimate the effectiveness of a stand-off ASW weapon. 3. Ka-25 Hormones may look cute, but they're deadly. 4. Get CIC Combat Plotter. I was doing this on graph paper and it possibly showed. 5. Don't play naval aviation if you're time-stretched (I was and voted for ENDEX when it was offered after the second SSN sinking) 6. Harpoons aren't all powerful. 7. Everyone makes mistakes at the beginning. 8. Putting yourselves in the other side's shoes is a good idea. 9. Soviet sonobuoys are hopeless. 10.SA-N-4s can take out seaskimmers. If you use 12 of them. I'd like to thank all the players for being great sports. I would also like to thank the Umpire and Assistant Umpire for their great running of the game. Let's do this again sometime, shall we? Silent Hunter 27 July 2009
-
Surge Into the Barents Fourms are open
My AAR. Hope you like it.
-
The Sixth Battle Arrived!
I finished The Sixth Battle a while ago. Great book.
-
High Tide: Kola Strike
Could I be a dual-side lurker please?
-
Tactics
Running away fast is always risky. You could go deep and slow (or deep and not so slow), or maybe stay close to the surface if the weather is bad and hope to get lost in the 'clutter'. Or you could just put a couple of torpedoes into him.
-
Some Naval Questions
Thanks for all that. I forgot you'd already answered about the DDG 1000.
-
Covert-81
Monday, June 8, 1981- 0600 Local Time, just outside Sverdlovsk, USSR As the clock ticked over to 0000 GMT, the sleek, deadly bomber flew at about 540 knots due west of the city of Yekaterinburg, then known as Sverdlovsk, which looked rather pretty in the dawn light. It was skimming barely 350 feet above the ground. The bomber was long and thin, painted grey on the top and white on the bottom. Behind the upturned nose and the four-man, two-compartment cockpit, were two swinging wings, currently in the un-swept position. Behind them were the twin tail cannon and the single tail. Nestled in the bomb bay- which was currently open because the thing didn’t fit inside, was a stand-off missile packed with high explosive. On each side of the tail were the number 74 in green and a single red star, the latter replicated on each side of the two wings. The red star was the symbol of the air force of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics- and this was a Backfire bomber. Covert-81 In the co-pilot’s seat, Lieutenant General of Aviation Arkady Arkhipovich Markov, Air Force commander of the Kiev Military District, was grinning like a schoolboy who’d just got full marks on a hard test, although you couldn’t see this under his oxygen mask. He glanced over at the test pilot, joy in his voice. “My compliments to OKB Tupolev, Pasha”, he said, speaking with a hint of a Ukrainian accent. The test pilot smiled too. “It is a great aircraft, isn’t it, Comrade Lieutenant General?” he commented. “Indeed, Comrade Major”, Markov replied, “The current Tu-22M versions scare the imperialists already. This will give them even more sleepless nights”. Since the Tupolev Tu-22M medium-range bomber, designated Backfire by NATO, had entered service seven years earlier, the Western military community had undergone one of those collective panics that it had done with other Soviet systems, such as the Tu-16 Badger, the aircraft Markov had originally flown and the M-4 Bison, the heavy bomber now largely relegated to tanker duties. The imperialists were so scared of this “strategic aircraft” (partly because they’d considerably over-estimated the already considerable range of the aircraft) that they had got his government to remove its capability for in-flight refuelling. This was the Tu-22M3, the newest version of this brilliant aircraft. Markov’s command would soon receive them, but he’d been offered this ride for the time being. The test pilot was flying the aircraft from Poltava, in the Ukrainian SSR on a mission to. He was waiting to hear from the range officer at the weapons range outside Tyumen to give him clearance to launch the single Kh-22 cruise missile he was carrying. The Kh-22, called the AS-4 Kitchen by NATO, could carry (depending on the version) a 1000 kg high-explosive warhead or a nuclear device with 350 kilotons worth of yield a distance over 200 miles against a ship or a land target. This would be another two minutes before he got the go-ahead to fire the missile for a test launch. Markov looked at the mountains, as the pilot pulled back the stick to start climbing to optimum launch altitude. “So, Pasha”, he asked the pilot, whose name was Pavel Kryakov, “Where are you from?” “Kazan”, the pilot replied, the previous confidence having disappeared, “Comrade Lieutenant General, there’s something concerning me”. “What, Pasha?” Markov asked. “It’s the military situation in Europe. I’m concerned that we’re losing our advantage in the conventional front- that we will not be able to defeat the imperialist forces in a war”. Markov thought about this. This was definitely contrary to the official line on things, but the pilot seemed really concerned. “Explain your reasoning”. “Right now, Comrade, we outnumber the NATO forces in Europe considerably, in most areas. We could probably force them to sue for peace or choose to use atomic weapons, with all the implications that entails. That alone is sufficient to deter the West starting a war”. “Indeed, that is the case”. “However, there are new weapon systems entering or soon to enter NATO service that we currently don’t have equals to”. “Like?” The F-15, which the Syrians have been having problems with- and is known to be a brilliant fighter. The F-16 fighter-bomber. The Tornado bomber, the new Mirage 2000, the new US attack submarines and cruisers, the new US super carriers and their aircraft. The list goes on. There’s a bigger concern too- this new ‘stealth fighter’”. “Surely we have far superior numbers for our defensive forces, Pasha and the new air-to-air missiles are apparently excellent”. “We do, but that won’t be enough. If we went to war now, we’d have a good chance of winning. If it happened in two years time, it would be about evens. Two years beyond that. I think the Americans know that and I worry about their new President. He seems a bit of a cowboy”. Pasha got the range confirmation and nodded to the offensive systems operator, who did the final checks on the missile. “Missile ready”, came the reply, “Ready to launch”. “Here we go, sir”, Pasha said as he opened the safety guard and pressed the launch switch. Markov did not respond as the Kitchen fell away from the aircraft, fired up its engine and flew towards its target at twice the speed of sound. The pilot pulled the Backfire into a sharp turn. You’ll get your good chance soon enough, Pasha, Markov thought, if I have anything to do with it. Whether Moscow approves or not...
-
Some Naval Questions
Reading some of the naval blogs I subscribe to, I'm a bit out of my depth. Can you help me? 1. What's the big issue with the DDG-1000? What are its advantages/disadvantages over more DDG-51? 2. What's a Future Surface Combatant and is it the same thing as the Royal Navy are planning to order to replace the Type 22/23 frigates? 3. Explain the Littoral Combat Ship to me and the controversy over that. 4. When does the US need to start building more cruisers to replace the Ticos? On other subjects: 1. If the PRC are completing Varyag, when would we be likely to see it in service? 2. Are the Russians actually building vessels at a half-decent rate now? 3. What, in your opinon, is the next "big thing", naval-wise?
-
Fiction section
Can I add my opening post to Covert-81? It features a "Backfire".
-
Fiction section
What I think this ought to be are stories using the Harpoon system and world it portrays, that is naval/air ops. For example, IC after action-reports (like SITREP #35) and original stories. I think we should also have a list of recommended novels, such as Red Storm Rising and The Sixth Battle.
-
Firr Ball
Since everyone else is doing it… I want to see if the infamous Yak-38 “Forger” is actually any good in combat, or for just for shooting down patrol aircraft. Note, I’m using an online dice-roller for this. Scenario The year is 1985. Four A-7Es (ATA 1.0 due to being fully loaded), launched from a US carrier, are attempting to conduct an airstrike on Kiev. They are all carrying: - 1 20mm Vulcan (ATA 4.0) - 2 AIM-9M (ATA 6.5) - 4 Mk 84, which only serve to reduce their base ATA to 1.0. I want to see if keeping their bombs on makes any real difference. Four Yak-38Ms (ATA 3.0) are launched to intercept and destroy them. These carry: - 4 R-60M [AA-8 Aphid] (ATA 4.5) I am assuming that, since all the relevant weapons are short-range, everyone starts in a dogfight. The Yak-38Ms are vectored in by GCI and so start with advantage. The A-7Es are disadvantaged. Therefore, the Yaks have ((6 + 3 – 1)* 10) + 10) = a 90% chance of getting into position. The AA-8s have a 55% chance (taking the 2nd gen decoys into account) of hitting. The A-7s, in counterpart have (6 + 1 – 3 * 10)- 10 = 50% chance of getting into position for an AIM-9 shot and no chance of a cannon shot. The AIM-9s have a 60% chance of hitting. Target assignments: A-7 1 -> Yak 1 A-7 2 -> Yak 2 A-7 3 -> Yak 3 A- 7 4 -> Yak 4 Yak 1 -> A-7 4 Yak 2 -> A-7 1 Yak 4 -> A-7 2 Yak 3 -> A-7 3 So here we go! 0:00-0:30 A-7 1: 98, not in position A-7 2: 18, in AIM-9 position A-7 3: 28, in AIM-9 position A-7 4: 48, in AIM-9 position Yak 1: 16, in R-60 position Yak 2: 84, in R-60 position Yak 3: 25, in position Yak 4: 29, in position In order of firing: Yak 2 on A-7 3: 99- misses A-7 4 on Yak 4: 90- misses Yak 4 on A-7 2: 28- Hits! A-7 3 on Yak 3: 23, Hits! Yak 3 can’t shoot as it’s going down A-7 2 is also going down Yak 1 on A-7 4: 7, Hits! After 30 seconds, it’s 2-1 to the Forgers. 00:30-01:00 Yak 1 goes for A-7 1, while Yak 3 goes for A-7 3 A-7 1: 60, not in position A-7 3: 10, in position Yak 1: 54, in position Yak 2: 52, in position Yak 4: 19, in position Yak 1 on A-7 1: 29, hits! Yak 2 on A-7 3: 33, hits! Yak 4 doesn’t need to fire. No A-7s are left in the game. For sake of seeing what happened to our pilots per rule 8.1.3 (Aircrew Survival): A-7 1: Ejects, needs 7 cycles to recover A-7 2: Dies A-7 3: Ejects, needs 7 months to recover A-7 4: Ejects, needs 6 days to recover Yak 3: Dies Conclusions A bit of a miss-match, possibly. However, I thought that the superior AIM-9M would have given the A-7s a better chance in this fight. Clearly the Yak-38s had the advantage in terms of agility, they are after all VTOL aircraft (was thrust vectoring something Forger pilots were encouraged to). Clearly the Forger isn’t all that bad. Then again, this was against attack aircraft with plenty of advantages.
-
Fiction section
I'd be interested.
-
Jaguar GR.1 Strike on Ammunition Dump
Radar doesn't bounce off people anyway, although it does do nasty things to you if you're standing too close.
-
Firr Ball
Double the number of Floggers, I'd say. The Soviets went for numbers over quality.
-
Firr Ball
I think later MiG-21s were R-60/AA-8 capable, but I'm not sure. Remember, also that the -21 is a 60s aircraft, while the Hornet is 80s.
- Warplane Magazine
-
Jaguar GR.1 Strike on Ammunition Dump
The MiG-29 was definitely a feared opponent when it first appeared. It has suffered some reliability problems, particularly with earlier engines, and our (public) opinion of it has probably suffered in recent conflicts because it was either flown by poorly trained or inexperienced pilots or faced insurmountable odds. I think you will find that the Fulcrums flown by capable air forces (such as those that came over to unified Germany) are highly respected. Indeed- the off-boresight capability of the R-73/AA-11 was used by the Germans to beat F-16s in an exercise. That led to helmet-mounted sights being adopted widely in the West.
-
Warplane Magazine
Never heard of it. When was it published, BTW?
-
New Trilogy Air Rules
Plus the MiG-21 is a pretty agile little fighter. I would like one, actually.