Everything posted by Silent Hunter UK
-
A thought on cost overruns
Are you prepared to say that all the admirals, generals, DOD commissions, etc. are not allowed to make changes to design, ranges, speeds, equipment list and parts suppliers? Because almost all major contracts are plagued by these. Also congress gets into the act to change what's in a military program. The Bradley Fighting Vehicle was a prime example of this. It was modified so much that it bore very little resemblance to the armored personnel carrier that it was supposed to be. The JSF is in danger of the same issue of they keep adding stuff onto it. Every time it gets a few pounds heavier it gets that much slower and shorter-ranged. No, I wouldn't be prepared to say that. However, the initial RFP should be robust enough to avoid major changes.
-
The F-35 Saga
The last time the French did it was 19 March 2011. With the Dassault Rafales.
-
The F-35 Saga
Stealth is always a matter of degree, of course, so how much stealth does one need? And for what price? Enough to get into weapons range, of course... at a price that doesn't break the national bank. F-22 levels ideally. I can see a case for the -35B and the -35C, as stealthy manned carrier aircraft will be needed in the future and you can't take an F-22 on a carrier. The -35A, though... needs to shape up fast.
-
Japan may drop F-35 from shortlist
There might well be a case for cancelling the F-35A, IMHO. Not the B and C variants though.
-
Dutch army retire Leopard 2s
Aviation Week report
-
A thought on cost overruns
All future military contracts should be set at a fixed price on negotiation. Any budget overruns fall squarely on the head of the contracted company. It'll never happen, but it seems sensible.
-
The F-35 Saga
I don't advocate for any particular alternative, though I do see some merit in the RAAF's approach of buying an interim warplane (in the F/A-18E/F Super Hornet, incl an EA-18G-like option) and adopting a "wait and see" approach for JSF, i.e. waiting for the design to mature, and seeing if the cost and delay problems are resolved. I would prefer a stealthy aircraft over a non-stealthy one; this had better be worth the money.
-
Libya No Fly Zone
From what I can gather, HMCS Charlottetown, HMS Liverpool and FS Courbet were involved together in the same general action. Sounds like Liverpool and Courbet did the heavy hitting with their 4.5 inch and 3.9 inch guns, respectively, from around six miles offshore. Charlottetown's involvement seems to have been restricted to some 0.50 cal flavoured deterrent. Thanks for the clarification.
-
Libya No Fly Zone
Thanks for the news. HMS Liverpool did something similar the other day.
-
Blackfive - Iran Builds Missile Sites In Venezuela
I agree. My point was that those who have used ballistic missiles as "terror" weapons have failed to incur any decisive advantage by them. Iraq and Iran could only draw; the Russians won in 2008 by other means and Speer stated outright that Hitler's V-1 and V-2 project sucked up valuable resources that could have gone elsewhere.
-
Blackfive - Iran Builds Missile Sites In Venezuela
There's another thing - conventionally-armed ballistic missiles have been, on the whole, useless for hitting anything that's not a large city and so far have not been a war-winning weapon. When Gaddafi launched "Scuds" at Lampedusa back in 1986, he managed to miss the entirety of a 6 by 1.9 mile island...
-
Apache back at sea
Salt corrosion is an issue with anything maritime; the British suffered severe problems due to it back in 1982.
-
Blackfive - Iran Builds Missile Sites In Venezuela
Of course, my country actually has been attacked by ballistic missiles, so it might be worth recalling our experience back in 1944-5. The V-2s weren't all that successful, particularly due to British deception efforts that caused the Germans to walk their aim back until the mean point of impact was outside London. They certainly didn't cause any major disruption to the war effort, even if they did cause a relatively large number of deaths. It's also very unlikely Iran would be able to launch anywhere near the number of missiles that Germany did.
-
Thank the world for HarpGamer
Thank you for all your great work!
-
Splash One Mudhen
Fairly strictly using 4.1, although I plan to use 5 for Splash One Mudhen if it's released before then.
-
Why Wargaming Works
Thanks for the link, Brad!
-
Splash One Mudhen
My current larger plan involves reaching the conclusion of this game whenever that may be, running a TOAW III game that should be six months maximum (a turn a week) and then going on to do the Sixth Battle scenario.
-
What scenario piques your interest?
I'd be firmly interested.
-
CDR Salamander - Smear, sideline, marginalize - dismiss
I'm curious to know if he can provide any actual examples of such smearing because I have yet to see any.
-
Libya No Fly Zone
RAF destroys FROG-7 launchers, "Scud" transporters.
-
Last WWI combat veteran dies
Rest In Peace.
-
Requests for the HCDB (Official DB of HCE) and HCDB2
Absolutely. The images haven't been a priority for me because the DB is already a lot of work, but feel free to PM me. I'll start a thread linking to them, maybe someone will be able to convert them. Am I alone in actually preferring the line drawings from the older versions of HCE?
-
China unveils J-15 Flying Shark
[excerpt] Beijing is revealing pictures of its indigenously built J-15 Flying Shark design that is intended to populate the decks of its first aircraft carrier. It comes equipped with large surface area wings (for extra lift at low speeds) that fold (for a small footprint on a crowded aircraft carrier deck), reinforced landing gear (for high, sink-rate landings), a tailhook (for arrested landing on short carrier decks) and a light blue paint scheme to signal its role in the People's Liberation Army’s Navy. Small canards on the nose also are to help lower the landing speed and the tail cone has been shortened to avoid ramp strikes. [/excerpt] Full story
-
Is China developing a VSTOL fighter?
Very interesting. Thanks for that.
-
First RAF Voyager arrives in UK
BBC News story