Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

HarpGamer

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

CV32

Staff Pukes
  • Joined

Everything posted by CV32

  1. No, the DP value of any installation is not shown in the Platform Display. Personally, I think this is a good thing in the sense that it adds a degree of realism. After all, how many air commanders are able to instantly calculate that "X" amount of type "Y" munitions will be sufficient to destroy Target "Z" ? One can always check the PE, of course, if you really want to know the DP of a particular target, but I have found that experience is a good teacher and eventually you will get a "feel" for what you need to destroy a given target.
  2. This is the first in what will hopefully be a series of discussions on tactics in HCCE, inspired in part by Pete's suggestions. The first topic will be power projection or strike planning: These are my personal comments on Strike Planning. I like to borrow from the USAF's Targeting Guide, which is far more complex than necessary than required by HCCE, but it contains helpful principles and guidance. For example, for the purposes of this exercise, I assume that we have already determined what target we want to hit and what objectives we hope to achieve by hitting that particular target. Let's assume, as well, for the sake of our assessment, that our target is a point target, such as a bridge, protected by SAMs. 1. Weaponeering The first step might be weaponeering, that is, an assessment of the types and quantities of weapons estimated to achieve a desired level of damage to the target. This takes into account the vulnerability of the target, weapons effects/reliability and delivery accuracy, as well as damage criteria. Large bridges in the Harpoon Classic Commander's Edition (HCDB) have 800 damage points (DP). This includes the "Generic Large Bridge" and those bridges bearing specific names (e.g. Baghdad Rail Bridge). The "Generic Small Bridge" has 400 DP. At first glance, these values might seem a bit high for a "simple" point target like a bridge. However, bridges are remarkably tough targets. Think about the substantial engineering effort that must go into the design and construction of a bridge: it will be expected to stand up to the considerable abuse of both heavy traffic and the natural elements for a very long time. Another factor is that bridges (like airfields, in some respects) can often be readily repaired if the damage is not immediately catastrophic. (You usually have to drop multiple spans to take it out for an appreciable period of time). The DP values in the HCDB therefore try to take into account both factors. (Admittedly, it's a little abstract, but I think it works pretty well, especially since the AI cannot actively conduct repairs and thereby regain DP). If you're still not convinced, consider a couple of classic real life examples from Vietnam: the Paul Doumer Bridge over the Red River in Hanoi, and the Ham Rung ("Dragon's Jaw") near Thanh Hoa. The Paul Doumer bridge northeast of Hanoi served no fewer than four separate rail lines, and had a total of 18 large concrete piers that supported its length of just over a mile. Prior to 1972, despite countless attempts, and a huge expenditure of sorties, munitions and lives, the Paul Doumer was only dropped for a few weeks at a time before being quickly repaired. The first major strike against the bridge on 11 August 1967 saw the bridge absorb 94 tons of bombs in direct hits and near misses. Three of the bridge spans had been dropped into the river. Remarkably, however, the bridge was back in operation only 53 days after the strike. The next major attempt to drop the bridge came on 25 October 1967, this time with 63 tons of bombs. Again the bridge was knocked out, but less than a month later, the bridge was once again back in operation. On 14 December and 18 December 1967, another 90 tons of bombs were dropped. Still, the Paul Doumer Bridge remained, though badly shaken. Worse, the Dragon's Jaw bridge was never dropped. During the 1967-68 air campaign, 177 fighter-bombers were sent out and dropped 380 tons of bombs on the bridge before the bombings in the north were halted by Washington. It wasn't until mid 1972 that the Paul Doumer and Dragon's Jaw bridges were both finally put of commission. We'll return to the example of the Paul Doumer Bridge later as part of our discussion. So, what do we need to take out a 400 DP bridge ? Target vulnerability takes into account the susceptibility of a target to terminal effects or specific damage mechanisms of a munition. Given the robust nature of the target (typically constructed of concrete and steel), we'll need weapon characteristics that produce damage effects including penetration, blast, overpressure, etc. This means either a small number of weapons with very high DP or a very large number of weapons with smaller DP. What about delivery accuracy ? A bridge (regardless of how large) is in many respects a tough target to actually achieve a decent hit, let alone inflict sufficient damage. The desired mean point of impact (DMPI) is (or are) relatively small. This means we are going to want a significant degree of precision, and force preservation dictates that we will want to achieve this precision with the least expenditure of munitions possible. Therefore, it looks more likely at this point that we will be opting for a small number of weapons with very high DP. We also need to consider damage criteria, that is, what kind of a kill we desire (at a minimum) to achieve. Victory conditions in a given scenario may come into play here, in addition to other factors, but I usually look to achieve at least 33% damage in any given strike. In the case of a bridge, however, this might not be sufficient to achieve even a Mobility Kill (M-Kill), and in fact, we might need 75% or more to achieve a Catastrophic Kill (K-Kill). Other factors that ordinarily come into play include hit probability (pH), kill probability (pK) and weapon reliability. In terms of HCCE, all of these are in large part determined by the weapon's PH value. In other words, if the given weapon found in the HCDB can hit the target, it will inflict the equivalent DP factor. Let's go back to our Paul Doumer Bridge example for a bit. On 11 August 1967 the Paul Doumer Bridge was attacked by a flight of 26 F-105D Thunderchiefs (not including their escorts and other supporting aircraft, which I will mention again later), each carrying a pair of 3,000 lb iron bombs. That's over fifty in all. Three spans were dropped under this awesome bombardment, but it still wasn't enough to put the bridge out of action. What finally took it out ? The laser guided bomb (LGB). Though admittedly the damage to the Paul Doumer Bridge was cumulative, several strikes in mid 1972 settled the issue once and for all. On 10 May 1972, 16 F-4D Phantoms attacked the Paul Doumer bridge, 12 of them carrying a pair of the new 2000 lb LGBs. The next day, four more F-4Ds again attacked with LGBs, this time dropping several spans. After several more attacks with LGBs, the bridge wasn't rebuilt until after the ceasefire in 1973. (The troublesome Dragon's Jaw bridge followed two days later, in even more summary fashion. It took some specially built 3,000 lb LGBs, but resulted in one end of the bridge being lifted off its abutment and tossed into the river). There are numerous precision guided munitions that might fit the bill for our 400 DP "Small Bridge Target", depending on the player's order of battle. Most of these are built around a 2,000 lb bomb (often the US Mk 84) or a similar heavy warhead. Smaller warheads or those designed to maximize penetration often lack sufficient brute blast force to destroy a bridge. Some examples of laser guided bombs from the HCDB include: (1) the US GBU-10 Paveway I/II series (especially those with DP 72) (2) the French BGL-1000 (DP 67) (3) the Russian KAB series (ranging from DP 65 for the 750 kg KAB-750L up to DP 100 for the 1,000 kg KAB-1500L) There are also a range of guided bombs and missiles with standoff capability (permitting the launch aircraft to avoid the lethal envelope of enemy point defences, which we will discuss later). Again, these often center on a 2,000 lb or similar weight warhead, and include: (1) the GBU-15(V)1/2 or its rocket powered cousin, the AGM-130A (with DP 72 and 71, respectively) (2) the US/Israeli AGM-142A Have Nap (DP 68) (3) the Hakim PGM-2000 used by the United Arab Emirates (DP 72) (4) the Israeli SPICE Mk 84 (DP 72) (5) the Russian AS-14 Kedge (TV guided Kh-29T or laser guided Kh-29L) (DP 63) For really long range standoff, stealth and accuracy (all of which comes at an expensive price tag, of course), you might opt for a cruise missile, such as either of: (1) the US AGM-158A JASSM or the TLAM-C series (both with DP 76) (2) the European Storm Shadow or Taurus KEPD350 (both with DP 67) Some simple math comes into play here. If our bridge target has 400 DP, we're going to need a minimum of four or five 2,000 lb class weapons to inflict the kind of catastrophic damage (a K-Kill) that we are looking for. So, now we know what weapons might be available to kill our bridge target. But how many aircraft we will need to deliver them ? 2. Force Application We must now use the information generated by the weaponeering phase to determine the best force necessary to meet our operational objectives. We assume we have good intelligence about the target (haha, big assumption, huh) and a recommendation for a weapon system. Now our operations and intelligence staff (which, in HCCE terms, refer to the left and right sides of your brain) must merge their planning efforts. A first step in this phase might be to prepare a tentative force assignment, that is, a "mission package". Again, our example of the Paul Doumer Bridge provides some useful historical guidance. The first major strike on the bridge, conducted on 11 August 1967, comprised the following mission package: - 26 F-105D Thunderchiefs, each carrying a pair of 3,000 lb iron bombs - two F-105D Thunderchief "Wild Weasel" aircraft, each protected by two wingmen and all armed with anti-personnel bombs - four F-4C Phantoms conducting flak suppression near the target - more F-4Cs flying high altitude MiGCAP - several EB-66 Destroyer "College Eye" aircraft orbiting high over the strike force, jamming enemy radar and alerting the MiGCAP of the approach of any hostile fighter aircraft - pairs of RF-4C Phantoms to fly in over the target area and conduct bomb damage assessment (BDA) after the strike - KC-135 tankers to provide refueling of the Thunderchiefs and Phantoms as they came off the target All of the usual elements of a mission package are represented here: the strike aircraft, the fighter escort, the SEAD (suppression of enemy air defences) escort, the airborne early warning and electronic warfare support, the reconnaissance aircraft, and the refuelers. How many of each might we need for our own bridge target ? While the Paul Doumer Bridge attack called for a flight of 26 strike aircraft and a total of 52 very large bombs, keep in mind that they were dealing with a very robust target and were using unguided munitions dropped from relatively unsophisticated aircraft. Large margins were introduced to boost chance of success. Should we do the same in our own example ? Of course. It is almost always best, should conditions permit, to choose more than one target and weapon combination. This allows planners to have greater flexibility. Personally, I like to use a factor of at least 1.5 to 3, dependent on the difficulty of the target, as well as my own capabilities and those of my adversary. This means we are going to need three to six strike aircraft, each carrying a pair of bombs (most modern types are comfortable carrying a pair of 2,000 lb class weapons). How about escorts ? For the offensive counter-air mission (i.e. dealing with enemy interceptors inside enemy airspace), I like to use a factor of 1-2. This means that every strike aircraft will have at least one, and preferably two, fighter escorts. Again, this depends on factors like the number of enemy fighters I am likely to encounter, and the distance from friendly airspace to the target. The capability of my strike aircraft to carry their own defensive air-to-air missiles also comes into play here, since many modern strike/attack aircraft are quite capable of defending themselves. Beyond visual range (BVR) capable air-to-air weapons (e.g. AIM-120 AMRAAM) are preferable. For the SEAD mission (i.e. dealing with enemy SAM/AAA defences), I go back to the 1.5 to 3 factor. Why ? Because I may have to fight my way to the target, hitting SAM and AAA installations on the way, as well as dealing with point defences that might be situated near the bridge. Also, SEAD is often a "make or break" factor when it comes to a strike mission. Enemy fighters can often be diverted, distracted, or avoided, but flying a strike package into the teeth of a defensive SAM envelope is often suicidal. Also, while cluster bombs served well enough during the Vietnam war, to suppress 37mm, 57mm and 85mm flak batteries, they are less than adequate in today's battle environment. Modern "double-digit" SAMs like the SA-10 often require generous applications of sophisticated anti-radar missiles (like the AGM-88 HARM or ALARM) to suppress the supporting radar systems, and wherever possible, this should be followed by precision delivery of a heavier weapon, like an LGB, to physically destroy the site. Airborne early warning (AEW) and jamming support go hand in hand with the SEAD escort. In the case of electronic warfare (EW), sometimes the SEAD escorts are also the jamming platforms, as is the case with aircraft like the EA-6B Prowler and EA-18G Growler. It is usually not possible, however, to provide 1.5 to 3 times as many jamming aircraft as there are strike aircraft; the EW aircraft are simply too rare and too valuable. Therefore, the bulk of the SEAD aircraft are usually made up of ARM (anti-radar missile) capable strike aircraft like the F-16C/D, F/A-18E or Tornado, rather than specializing jamming platforms like the Prowler or Growler. AEW aircraft (like the E-3 Sentry or E-2 Hawkeye) are even more scarce, and generally unable to take on the kind of risks that EW and SEAD aircraft are capable of. They might have to remain outside hostile airspace, require their own heavy fighter escort, and might not be able to provide a constant radar surveillance umbrella over the mission package. In most cases, I will simply push my AEW asset as close to enemy airspace and/or the target as I dare, without endangering the asset or expending too much extra support. In most cases, I can extract some degree of advantage from the AEW coverage for the bulk of the ingress and egress phases of the strike mission. Bomb damage assessment (BDA) requirements are not something that is modeled very well in HCCE, at least not with fixed installation targets like a bridge. You know the results of your strike as soon as it is carried out, and the damage is expressed as a percentage value. If your target were a mobile one, like a ship or a SAM launcher, you would only know the results of your strike as long as you had firm contact with that target. BDA is performed by reconnaissance aircraft after the strike is over, but often it is useful to conduct reconnaissance of the target prior to the arrival of your mission package. In terms of HCCE, this is especially true when trying to determine the extent of the enemy's air defences in proximity to the target or along your intended route. Mobile SAM launchers, AAA guns and manportable air defence systems (MANPADS) are invisible to the player until and unless discovered by the appropriate sensors. Conducting pre-strike reconnaissance might serve to reveal these dangers, but it might also alert them. Your call … Finally, whether your mission package will require in-flight tanking support will be entirely dependent on the capabilities of your aircraft and the range from their home base to the target and back. If your aircraft have "long legs", you might get away with a minimum of aerial tanker support. As with AEW aircraft, tankers are quite valuable, vulnerable and need to be protected. If you're really lucky, you have aircraft that are capable of carrying both "buddy stores" and defensive air-to-air missiles. Some major considerations to remember in the context of HCCE: (1) your tankers can only refuel single aircraft or a group of aircraft, and can do so one time only; and (2) be sure to allow for more than just simple Point A to Point B distance calculations, and keep in mind that your mission package might need to do some "bobbing and weaving" on both the ingress and egress. 3. Execution Planning Once we have determined the size and composition of our mission package, its time to prepare the actual tasking, construction and subsequent execution of your mission. This includes how you will employ your aircraft and what tactics you will use. This inevitably leads into an area that is much more expansive than intended here, but I will say the following: I don't assemble all of my mission package components into a single group (even if they are all located at the same base), and I will usually split them up according to their various roles (strike, escort, etc.). If there are sufficient numbers, I will also split up the strike and escort elements into smaller groups to add more flexibility. If I can afford it, I will often assemble a separate offensive counter-air mission (a sweep and escort, essentially) and send it ahead of the strike mission package in order to determine, disrupt and divert enemy air defences. Wherever possible, I will have my mission package approach the target from a direction other than direct path, and do the same on the egress. I am sure other people around here have more to add, but I hope this helps. Brad
  3. After reading Herman's comment, it immediately occurred to me: what would anyone do after finding a single mine ? Start looking around for more, right ? It only seems natural to me that once one mine is found, the others quickly follow. There might be some room left for tweaking the "stealth factor" with mines, but I find they work fairly well in the sim. The purpose of mines after all is not really so much to stay invisible, and sink random ships (although that is always a bonus), but rather to be discovered, to foster fear and apprehension, and to thereby block, impede and slow down freedom of movement.
  4. CV32 replied to pmaidhof's topic in General
    Great suggestion, Pete. These concepts, once developed, could become "Stickies" on the forum. This section is best used for "tactics" and the Scenario Design section for "scenario work". I see Herman has stepped up to help you with the scenario aspect. You guys should post your conclusions there. (I'll add quips if need be). And as far as tactics goes, is there a topic that you would like to start with ?
  5. From DefenseNews U.S., EU Tentatively Back Russian Atom Plan for Iran By FRANCOIS MURPHY, REUTERS, VIENNA A Russian plan aimed at satisfying the world that Tehran’s atomic aims are peaceful has won tentative backing from the United States and the European Union’s top powers, diplomats said on Nov. 10. Under the proposal, supported by France, Britain and Germany, known as the EU3, and Washington, Iran would keep part of its atomic fuel production program if the most sensitive part, uranium enrichment, was scrapped and moved to Russia, diplomats say. Mohamed ElBaradei, director-general of the U.N.’s International Atomic Energy Agency, supports the compromise and said he hoped a deal would be reached soon. “He hopes that in the coming days the international community will be able to coalesce around a solution that is acceptable to all parties, including Iran,” the IAEA said in a statement. Diplomats, however, were skeptical that Iran would join the proposed Russian joint venture, as that would mean Tehran renouncing enrichment, which it says it will never do. Enrichment purifies uranium for use as fuel in power plants or, if it is enriched further, for use in bombs. “What ElBaradei said may be wishful thinking,” an EU3 official told Reuters on condition of anonymity. “Perhaps the Iranians will make a deal with us, but I think we will be surprised if that happens.” Tehran denies accusations from Washington that it is trying to build nuclear weapons under cover of its atomic power program. It has so far made no clear response to the recent Russian proposal. Talks Continue The details of a proposal were, however, still being negotiated, diplomats said. “There is no U.S.-European proposal to the Iranians. I want to say that categorically,” U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice told reporters en route from Washington to the Middle East. “We are doing what we have been doing for some time which is keeping diplomatic partners apprised of their thinking about the future of their negotiations with the Iranians,” she added. A diplomat familiar with U.S.-IAEA discussions said Washington had made clear that it wanted Iran to react to any proposal by an IAEA board of governors meeting on Nov. 24. The Americans “have said they want the Iranians to take action by the meeting, not just on this proposal but on all the issues of non-compliance covered at the previous meeting”, he said. Under the Russian plan, Iran could continue with uranium conversion, the step before enrichment — something the West had previously wanted Iran to renounce, too. Talks between the EU3 and Iran collapsed in August after Iran resumed conversion activities. Senior EU3 officials met Russian and Chinese envoys in Vienna on Nov. 10, an EU3 official said. The head of South Africa’s delegation to the IAEA said if Iran accepted an offer, other states would back the plan. “If Iran agrees, then everybody will support it,” Abdul Minty told Reuters. ElBaradei said he was prepared to go to Tehran if it helped. “Dr. ElBaradei has a standing invitation to visit Iran, and while he has no plans to do so at present, he is ready to travel to Iran at an appropriate time if it will help facilitate a solution,” the IAEA statement added. Germany’s designated foreign minister made it clear the European powers still did not trust the Islamic republic. He said Tehran is not being fully open with U.N. inspectors about its nuclear program and may still be hiding something. “There is a lack of transparency. That is clear,” Frank-Walter Steinmeier said in Berlin. “We still have some suspicions that there are developments being pursued (by Iran) that go against this principle.” — Additional reporting by Louis Charbonneau and Mark Trevelyan in Berlin; Paul Hughes in Tehran; Madeline Chambers in London; Maria Golovnina in Moscow, and Saul Hudson in Washington.
  6. From Defense Aerospace South African Gripen Makes Its Maiden Flight (Source: Gripen International; issued Nov. 14, 2005) The first South African dual seat Gripen took to the skies on its maiden flight in Sweden on Friday 11 November 2005. Painted in South African Air Force grey livery, the aircraft took off at 13.40 from Saab’s Flight Test Centre in Linköping, Sweden. The flight lasted 1 hr 10 min. South African test pilot Charl Coetzee and Saab test pilot Magnus Olsson were at the controls for the first flight of South Africa’s future multi-/swing-role fighter. During the flight, the test team were able to validate the basic flight control systems, engine, hydraulics and electrics. “The flight went better than expected and we were able to demonstrate some additional functionalities,” explained Charl Coetzee. “The maiden flight of South Africa’s first Gripen is an important milestone which has been achieved earlier than scheduled. This is indicative of the maturity of the Gripen design and the dedicated approach taken by joint Swedish-South African teams to keep the program on track for customer deliveries commencing in March 2008,” remarked Jerker Ahlqvist, Program Director, South Africa. This aircraft will now undergo a thorough inspection and systems computer interrogation before being prepared for subsequent flight tests commencing later this month. It will be transferred to South Africa in August 2006, where it will participate in a flight development program focused on the integration of South Africa’s customized avionics and weapons systems.
  7. From Defense Aerospace New Torpedoes and Combat System for Collins Class Submarines (Source: Australian Department of Defence; issued Nov. 14, 2005) Australia’s Collins-Class Submarines are undergoing a major capability boost with work about to start fitting out the first submarine with a new tactical combat system and upgraded state-of-the-art Heavyweight Torpedoes. Defence Minister Robert Hill said the design and installation of the Replacement Combat System and Heavyweight Torpedo System are on schedule and on cost. Senator Hill said the $857 million capability investment will significantly boost the combat effectiveness of the Collins Class making them the most capable diesel-electric submarines in the world today. Senator Hill said the first combat system has been delivered and is currently undergoing integration with Australian components and sensors at HMAS Stirling in Western Australia. When complete the systems will be put through a rigorous testing program before going to sea in the first submarine. "The first submarine to be fitted out with the new systems will be HMAS Waller which is currently docked at Adelaide’s ASC facility," Senator Hill said. "HMAS Waller will be ready to start sea trials with the new capabilities in early 2007 after being fitted out with the new systems during the next 12 months. "Once the trials have been completed, HMAS Waller will be at the cutting edge of diesel-electric submarine technology." The combat system and the new Heavyweight Torpedo system are to be installed in all Australian submarines by 2010, resulting in a major capability boost to the Collins fleet. "The Australian Navy is working together with the United States Navy on the development of the new Heavyweight Torpedo program. "The first test firings of the new weapon in Australian waters occurred in September during a joint exercise involving a US Navy Submarine and an Australian Collins Class Submarine off the Western Australia coast. "The test firing was a significant milestone in the joint development program between the two Navies. "Cooperating with the US Navy means we have the opportunity to influence design and development of the systems and to participate in a continuous improvement program to deliver the latest technology advances for Australia’s submarine fleet. "Australia’s Submarine fleet is an important element of our National Maritime Strategy and a vital asset in the protection of Australia's strategic interests."
  8. CV32 replied to pmaidhof's topic in General
    To recap our discussion on IRC for the benefit of those who weren't there, Tony says that two Prowlers are better than one, but three aren't better than two. Basically, with two Prowlers, their jamming systems work to mask each other.
  9. Nice AAR, Herman. Thanks for trying my scenario. I think you're actually talking about the H-6 Badgers here, because the Beagles carry only iron bombs. Thanks again.
  10. CV32 replied to CV32's topic in Shore Leave
    Hehe, a valiant attempt, but its not the story I'm looking for. Wahoo ! Er ... sorry ... got carried away.
  11. CV32 replied to CV32's topic in Shore Leave
    Aarghh ... no, that's correct. Alright, you big brained smart-aleck's ... here's another: Circa 1980, you are a pilot with the PVO's 787 IAP. Suddenly, the klaxon rings, and the coded alarm call comes ... Jastreb ! What is happening ? (Hehe, I think I have you now, Mr. Page and Mr. Brin ... )
  12. CV32 replied to CV32's topic in Shore Leave
    Grrrr ... Google proves my nemesis once again ... of course, the share price is nice. Here's another ... In August 2001, the captain of the Richard Laborde was elevated to a new command. What was his new ship ?
  13. CV32 replied to CV32's topic in Shore Leave
    The next trivia question ... When was the first unmanned flight of the B-2 Spirit stealth bomber ?
  14. Well put, Akula. 100% accuracy would be impossible to achieve, in any event. We're not Lockheed Martin or Boeing (if, hypothetically speaking, their RCS testing facilities were in fact able to achieve 100% accuracy ... ). Tony makes a good point about loiter turn rate, one that I hadn't thought about much until now. Most of the reports of "sneak attacks" have involved their combat air patrol (CAP) aircraft being caught with their pants down. It may be that players will have to put more thought into setting up their patrols rather than simply sending their aircraft to a specific point on the map.
  15. CV32 replied to CV32's topic in Shore Leave
    Alright, enough waiting. Here's the answer: The much maligned (but mostly misunderstood, IMHO) Stryker wheeled armored vehicle (previously known as the Interim Armored Vehicle) is named in honor of two American soldiers who were awarded the Medal of Honor (posthumously). Pfc Stuart S. Stryker, who served with the 513th Parachute Infantry during WWII, led an attack near Wesel, Germany, that resulted in the capture of more than 200 of the enemy and the rescue of three American pilots. Spc Robert F. Stryker, who served with the 1st Infantry Division in Vietnam, was decorated for saving the lives of his comrades near Loc Ninh. There, now don't you feel like you should have got that one ? Brad
  16. I agree, Akula. I think the RCS model (thank you, Tony !) has added a new level to the sim and can really demand that you stay on your toes. The RCS ratings are not perfect by any means (I don't use a mathematical model or chart of known or "expected" radar cross section values down to the 0.0001 sq.m, for example), but they generally follow the H4.1 signature rules. If I am surprised by an aircraft that I thought I should have detected, then most times I like to chalk it up to the enemy's clever use of terrain to mask his approach. Terrain is not modeled in HCCE, but with a little imagination ... I think most players who are uncomfortable with being surprised this way have become too accustomed to the "old way" of playing Harpoon Classic. They need to start thinking "outside the box", because their foe most certainly will.
  17. After some further research ... you shouldn't feel too terrible if an L-39 manages to put the hurt on you. Apparently, during the recent NATO Air Meet 2005 exercise in Orland, Norway, a Czech Air Force L-159 ALCA (a very similar aircraft, albeit somewhat more advanced) was able to target and "shoot down" an F-16 (Norwegian ?). I don't know if that speaks to the caliber of the aircraft, the skill of the Czech pilot or the failure of the Norwegian pilot, or a combination of all three, but at the very least, it tells you to never underestimate your opponent.
  18. CV32 replied to CV32's topic in Shore Leave
    Ok, here's a hint since you seem to be stumped. The link is directly related to how soldiers get around (ie. travel) in Iraq.
  19. Welcome, toorabid. Most all questions are good ones, this one included. The older battlesets (EC2000 and previous) are incompatible with the new player editable database. Therefore, afaik, one cannot create the Tu-22MP Backfire D and backwards import it into an EC2000 scenario. My best suggestion would be to create a whole new scenario (perhaps based on "Blockers" if that is what you want to do) in an EC2003 battleset.
  20. I checked this out. Turns out the L-39 has the same RCS rating in the HCDB as do many other aircraft of its size and vintage. No obvious problems here.
  21. From Navy Times Converted Ohio ready for sea trials By Christopher Munsey Times staff writer The guided-missile submarine Ohio, the first of four former Trident ballistic missile boats undergoing conversion to the new SSGN mission, is scheduled to start sea trials soon. Ohio recently finished a nuclear reactor refueling and conversion process at Puget Sound Naval Shipyard in Washington, said Kevin Sykes, a Naval Sea Systems Command spokesman. Four former Trident submarines, including Ohio, Georgia, Florida and Michigan, are being converted to SSGNs, at a total cost of approximately $4 billion. Instead of Trident nuclear-warhead tipped missiles, the new SSGNs will carry an arsenal of up to 154 Tomahawk cruise missiles, and serve as special operations platforms. As part of the conversion, the battery of 24 Trident missile tubes were removed, freeing up space for cruise missile canisters and storage space. Officials have said an SSGN will be able to host as many as 66 SEALs or Special Operations forces, along with transporting a mini-submarine called the Advanced SEAL Delivery System, and a dry deck shelter with a SEAL Delivery Vehicle. Following sea trials and after completing testing and training, Ohio is expected to be available for deployment sometime in 2007, Sykes said. Conversion work is on schedule on Georgia, Florida and Michigan, with all three conversions complete by September 2007.
  22. CV32 replied to pmaidhof's topic in General
    One reason (probably an atypical one) that comes to mind is anonymity. I might want to energize an air search radar that is the same as, or comparable to, a radar used by other (perhaps neutral) ship types. That way, I could maintain a degree of stealth and yet still collect useful air search information.
  23. LGBs or JDAM would have been my choice. TLAM's are plenty accurate, most of the time, but they're also very valuable, very expensive and you need good intel to target them effectively. I would have reserved the TLAM's for a strike against a target inside enemy territory, and used the bombs against a target like Naha where my pilots can actually "eyeball" their aimpoints. Couldn't agree more. Oh, to have had a few "personal use" TLAM's available over the years.
  24. Great AAR, though I must admit to shuddering a little at the thought of your choosing to paste Naha with forty ALCM's. I don't like to impose restrictions on players and their choice of tactics, but you do realize that it was an enemy "occupied" base adjacent to a civilian population, right ? Perhaps you have heard of "economy of force" ? Hehe, just razzing ya, Herman. Where would the community be without your AAR's ?
  25. Interesting article, though unfortunately it doesn't tell us much about how the shootdown was actually achieved. My understanding is that the Serbs took advantage of known approach routes (due to NATO constraints); the media coverage of activity at Aviano airbase in Italy, and the presence in "spies" in Italy who passed timely reports of air activity. Using this information, the Serbs were able to calculate, more or less, when an Allied aircraft was enroute. This particular SA-3 battery wasn't previously known to Allied intel, and the F-117 passed close to this unknown danger. When the F-117 opened its bomb bay doors, it momentarily became visible to radar, enough for the Serbs to take a shot. They may have even guided the missile optically. A combination of bad counter-intel, bad luck and undoubtedly, more than a little Serb ingenuity.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.