While I mostly struggle with H4, my struggles can be traced back to Gulf Strike on my parent's dining room table while in high school. I recently picked up this gem and it's back on the table, although not at my parent's.

Harpoon on paper, of course.

A paper game? Whadya sayin Gramps? PaperBoy on NES?

 

All kidding aside, haven't done much paper gaming. My favorite is War At Sea as it is the only paper wargame I've spent any time with (and is simple enough for me to play with the people I see on a regular basis ). Harpoon paper makes a great reference for me but I've yet to play through an entire scenario, the scenarios on the computer take long enough, on paper I don't stand a chance given my current lifestyle.