Everything posted by HG S2 (Intel Bot)
-
Defence Blog - Russia tests new bomb in strike on Ukrainian city
Russian forces have used a newly developed guided aerial bomb for the first time in a strike against Ukraine, according to Ukrainian officials. The attack, carried out by a Su-34 bomber, hit civilian targets in the city of Kharkiv with two UMPB-5 precision-guided munitions fired from approximately 100 kilometers away. The strike, launched from near […] The post Russia tests new bomb in strike on Ukrainian city first appeared on Defence Blog.View the full article
-
Defence Blog - Russia ramps up kamikaze drone production with Chinese help
Russia has sharply increased its production of Garpiya-A1 attack drones despite Western sanctions, according to documents reviewed by Reuters and cited by European security officials. The documents show that Izhevsk Electromechanical Plant Kupol (IEMZ Kupol), a sanctioned Russian defense manufacturer, boosted its annual output of the Garpiya-A1—Moscow’s domestically produced version of the Shahed-class drone—from 2,000 […] The post Russia ramps up kamikaze drone production with Chinese help first appeared on Defence Blog.View the full article
-
Defence Blog - Thai F-16 jets hit Cambodian targets after border attack
The Royal Thai Air Force carried out air strikes against two Cambodian military targets on Thursday, after a surprise assault earlier in the day. According to Royal Thai Army deputy spokesperson Col. Ritcha Suksuwanon, six F-16 fighter jets were launched from Ubon Ratchathani province and struck ground targets inside Cambodia. “We have used air power […] The post Thai F-16 jets hit Cambodian targets after border attack first appeared on Defence Blog.View the full article
-
Defence Blog - ASELSAN unveils GOKTAN strike system at IDEF 2025
Türkiye’s defense electronics leader ASELSAN has introduced its new ground-based precision strike system, GÖKTAN, during the IDEF 2025 defense exhibition. The system is part of a broader suite of next-generation warfare technologies showcased by the company, aimed at meeting the changing needs of modern armed forces operating across multiple domains. According to ASELSAN, GÖKTAN is […] The post ASELSAN unveils GOKTAN strike system at IDEF 2025 first appeared on Defence Blog.View the full article
-
Defence Blog - France, UK, Belgium jets patrol Black Sea
The French military announced a joint air surveillance operation over the Black Sea on July 24, conducted in close coordination with British and Belgian forces. The operation aimed to enhance regional stability and safeguard the security of Europe’s southeastern flank amid ongoing concerns about access to international airspace and maritime freedom. The surveillance mission, conducted […] The post France, UK, Belgium jets patrol Black Sea first appeared on Defence Blog.View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Episode 24: 23JUL2025
Show LinksReforming the promotion system in DOD Australian Missile Canister Loading Equipment (MCLE) USNS Oscar V. Peterson (T‑AO 206) SummaryIn this episode of the Commander Salamander UNCLAS Read Board Podcast, the host discusses various topics related to national security, military developments, and the challenges faced by the Navy. Key themes include t… Read more View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - I Think we Might Know What We're Calling the F/A-XX
No, neither that pic above nor the one below is the F/A-XX, but it’s the closest we’ve got. However, let’s review the decades-long Salamander Requirements List we have set out for the next Navy tactical aircraft. All hail the return of the heavy fighter to the airwing: Range: It has to fight in the Pacific and engage other enemies from a distance. Payload: It must be able to carry at least a half-dozen AIM-174B Gunslinger, with a minimum of four of them internally. As the drone wars over Israel have proven its utility again, it must have an internal gun. Flexibility: Must perform air-to-air and air-to-ground missions like the Super Hornet it will replace.. Two Engines: We promised ourselves that the A-7 would be the last carrier aircraft with one engine. Then we accepted the F-35C compromise. Never again. Two Crewmembers: Time and again, the utility of heavy fighters with a dedicated pilot and weapon systems officer in combat has been proven. Tell the accountants, 1310-Mafia, and the perma-shore-duty cadre to pack sand. The dual-crewed heavy fighter can bring a carrier airwing nothing else can. The F-35 will be the “light fighter” niche for the airwing. Whatever we get, the “Bravo” model must be designated the EF-XXB. The Growler should fade away quicker than the Super Hornet. Its range is just way too limiting. The USAF has stolen a march on the Navy, and yes the picture at the top is in USAF livery. OK fine, here is another image of vaporware that scratches the same itch but Navy. …but take it for what it is. I’ve set the table, and let’s dive in to the topic. How did I miss this back in May? Via Audrey Decker at DefenseOne, In keeping with his penchant for shocking the defense industry, President Donald Trump today seemingly revealed plans to develop a twin-engine version of the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter known as the F-55, as well as an upgraded “F-22 Super.” But former Air Force Secretary Frank Kendall said he was “mystified by Trump’s comments,” and analysts said that what the president described would be a highly challenging engineering endeavor on par with creating a clean-sheet aircraft. They also questioned the wisdom of spending scarce budget dollars on a twin-engine advanced F-35 when the newly announced F-47 is already planned to fill that niche. “A two engine version of F-35 would be virtually a complete redesign,” Kendall told Breaking Defense. “It’s an option that was never presented and that we never considered, to my knowledge.” I’m going to have to explain this to everyone, aren’t I? There is a lot to sort through. “We’re doing an upgrade, a simple upgrade, but we’re also doing an F-55. I’m going to call it an F-55, and that’s going to be a substantial upgrade, but it’s going to be also with two engines, because an F-35 has a single engine. I don’t like single engines,” the president said during a press conference in Doha, the second stop on the first international trip of his second presidential term. “Even this man [GE Aerospace CEO Larry Culp], he’s the best in the world at engines, but on occasion, I know you won’t admit this, if an engine goes out it’s nice to have two, three or four. That’s why I like the 747, it’s got four. Today they’re getting very big and, a little more cost saving to have two very, very big ones. No matter how good, you know, they tell me, Larry, the engine will never go out. Well, I think it goes out on occasion, fairly rarely. “We’re going to do an F-55 and I think, if we get the right price, we have to get the right price, and that will be two engines, and a super upgrade on the F-35 and then we’re going to do the F-22. I think the most beautiful fighter jet in the world is the F-22, but we’re going to do an F-22 Super, and it will be a very modern version of the F-22 fighter jet.” … Trump appeared to indicate that the “F-55” would be a two-engine version of the F-35, but such a modification would require a comprehensive redesign of the airframe, essentially resulting in a new airplane. Trump’s comments come weeks after Lockheed Martin CEO Jim Taiclet said the company is working on an upgrade to “supercharge” the F-35 and deliver 80% of sixth-generation capability at half the price. But Lockheed is talking about better avionics and sensors, not a redesign to double the number of engines. How Trump’s proposed “F-55” coincides with Lockheed’s plans, if at all, remains to be seen. It is also possible that Trump was thinking about the two-engine F-47, a sixth-generation fighter jet that Boeing won the contract to build in March. Yet another possibility is that Trump was talking about the Navy’s F/A-XX, a different next-gen fighter jet intended to replace the F/A-18 Super Hornet. Boeing and Northrop Grumman are competing to design and build the F/A-XX, which is expected to have two engines. But the program is in limbo: some Pentagon officials want to delay the contract award up to three years to use the money elsewhere, Reuters reported on Wednesday. I guess I’m going to have to be the Trump Explainer. A lot of people Mike Stone at Reuters may be taking things a bit too literally. The timing of the F-55 announcement raises questions about how it fits into existing defense procurement plans and budgets. The Pentagon is already managing multiple high-cost aviation programs, including the ongoing F-35 program, the new F-47 development, and potentially the Navy's next generation carrier-based fighter jet - F/A-XX. For Lockheed Martin, the F-55 concept represents a critical opportunity to maintain relevance in the high-end fighter market after significant setbacks in next-generation competitions. Boeing's NGAD, which was just awarded and therefore is not in mass production yet, is expected to eclipse the F-22's capabilities, and so would F-55, the person said, making it a formidable fighter jet. Ditto the folks Valerie Insinna and Michael Marrow’s at Breaking Defense talked to. In keeping with his penchant for shocking the defense industry, President Donald Trump today seemingly revealed plans to develop a twin-engine version of the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter known as the F-55, as well as an upgraded “F-22 Super.” But former Air Force Secretary Frank Kendall said he was “mystified by Trump’s comments,” and analysts said that what the president described would be a highly challenging engineering endeavor on par with creating a clean-sheet aircraft. They also questioned the wisdom of spending scarce budget dollars on a twin-engine advanced F-35 when the newly announced F-47 is already planned to fill that niche. “A two engine version of F-35 would be virtually a complete redesign,” Kendall told Breaking Defense. “It’s an option that was never presented and that we never considered, to my knowledge.” Sigh. While I reserve the right to be wrong—let me tap into nine years of senior military staff weeniedom and a decade and a half working with pure-civilian entrepreneurs to help everyone get a handle on what is going on. If I can put my eye-twitching pedantry to one side about our refusal to keep proper numbering conventions for our aircraft to the side—what the Navy now calls “F/A-XX” is going to be called the F-55. Even though the USAF has rolled out their new fighter first, the next U.S. Navy fighter aircraft will debut during the Trump administration—likely sooner than later. He’s said the next fighter will be F-55. As no other fighters are under development right now, so shall it be. Oh, no F/A-55 either. Just F-35 and save millions of keystrokes and tons of ink. The F-35 talk is just what we discussed earlier this year; Lockheed’s desire to fold in technology from their failed bid for the NGAD/F-47 into an upgraded F-35. If that is done and produced, it will just—if we are logical about it—be a F-35D. The F-22 talk is either simply confusion or the byproduct of a brief about incorporating some aspects that we see, or wanted to see, in the F-22. President Trump has been briefed on the F-47 in details few have the clearance to see, possibly Lockheed’s options for what I called the F-35D above, and I would assume what we now call F/A-XX that—giggle—will almost certainly be called the F-55. His briefing likely discussed integrating technology from the F-22, F-35, and NGAD/F-47 competition into the Navy’s new fighter. He’s busy guy with what I think is the most active first six-months of any Presidency in my lifetime…so just assume he’s conflating a few things…but what should we boil down? We are close to seeing the selection of the Navy’s new fighter. It will have two engines. It will be called the F-55. That is your responsible takeaway. That is all we know. Hopefully, the end product will align with the Salamander Requirements List outlined at the top of the post. Some of the people quoted above give me the impression they are seeing roughly the same thing I am. Others who made comments like Kendall etc above? They either are vested in refusing to try to think about what Trump meant v. what he said, are excessively rigid in thinking, or they don’t function well in chaos. It is actually funny to read in places. Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - The Battle of the Ports is Afoot
Neither rust nor the People’s Republic of China (PRC) sleep. They are determined, persistent, and keep the long-term view—especially when it comes to their neo-mercantilist drive to dominate global trade and the ports. Remember when early on in the Trump Administration it seemed that BlackRock was going to buy back some of the critical port infrastructure that the PRC grabbed hold of while the world was distracted and pockets got itchy? Well, don’t think all is taken care of. Via James T. Areddy, Daniel Kiss & Ming Li in last Saturday’s WSJ: When a Hong Kong conglomerate set plans this year to sell its global network of shipping ports to an American-led investment group, two facilities in Panama got most of the attention. But the real action is in Europe, where Chinese business interests have spent decades accumulating port holdings. Hong Kong-based CK Hutchison agreed in March to sell more than 40 ports in 23 nations to an investor group led by American financial firm BlackRock, and the parties had aimed to reach a definitive agreement on the $23 billion deal at month-end. Now, Beijing is trying to muscle into the deal and carve out a stake for its giant shipping group Cosco, The Wall Street Journal reported Thursday. … The most substantial impact on China’s ambitions from the port deal might be in Europe, a continent crucial to Beijing’s trade and diplomatic ambitions. Nearly half of the facilities on the block are in Europe or North Africa. Trump’s trade tariffs, meanwhile, have Europe bracing for a deluge of Chinese goods that have been rerouted away from the U.S. Shipping volumes of items including electric vehicles are already up in places such as Spain. There are always second-order effects. Whether the deal goes through as planned or with Cosco’s participation, China’s port foothold in Europe would be concentrated under government-run companies similar to Cosco, which U.S. authorities consider a military-aligned enterprise. Exiting the region would be Hutchison, a private company controlled by the family of the 96-year-old Hong Kong billionaire capitalist Li Ka-shing, who hasn’t always seen eye-to-eye with Beijing. Do you feel like the PRC is playing everyone? Also, where are the European leaders? Every one of those ports is in a NATO nation. Does anyone have full confidence that should a general war break out in the Pacific with the PRC that those ports in NATO nations will just continue to function as normal? If you do, can I invite you to poker night? China’s port expansion strategy in Europe has primarily featured opportunistic acquisitions—a possible reason the Hutchison sale looks inviting to Cosco. “The European ports are the best in terms of asset and infrastructure, of international importance for trade,” said Liu of the Council on Foreign Relations, making them appealing investments. Government-run China Merchants took one of the boldest steps in 2013, buying 49% of a port business called Terminal Link from CMA CGM for 400 million euros. The deal gave China Merchants a minority share in a range of facilities, especially in Europe, and slivers in Miami and Houston. … Cosco itself first entered Europe as a ports investor in 2004 with a minority stake in a container facility in Antwerp, Belgium. Cosco then made inroads starting in 2008 buying a concession to run facilities south of the Greek capital Athens at Piraeus, which it transformed into a world-class port. Pertinent to today’s situation, Valencia in the 1980s was quick to adopt containerized shipping, which has been crucial to spurring world trade—and helped make China the world’s top exporter for 16 years. Beijing gained control of the Port of Valencia in a European financial crisis. Wall Street’s 2008-09 financial crisis had sparked major debt problems for corporate Europe, including for Spanish construction giant ACS Group. Insert cliché about selling the rope to hang you with. Who benefits…and who is willing to stand up for their nation with the same enthusiasm the PRC is showing to take from it? You have to respect the PRC’s consistency and success. h/t Gordon Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - The Nuclear Priesthood is Having a Moment
“The difference, of course, between the debate over the nature of thermonuclear war and previous such debates is that it remains hypothetical. And unless we want to bet everything on the optimist, that is what it will always be. For if we lost this bet, and the pessimist turned out to be right, a thermonuclear war will have destroyed the human race, and along with it things like discourse and memory. The debate would remain forever unresolved, because those pessimists proven right, along with those optimists proven wrong, would all be dead.” —Campbell Craig, Destroying the Village The Israeli-American attack on the Iranian has for now at least, brought the topic of the theory and practice of nuclear deterrence and its crazy sister nuclear war to the front of the discussion space. Two of my must-listen podcasts, Geopolitics Decanted and Net Assessment, have both discussed it this July. After a still ongoing exchange with Bob Peters that started on the Sabbath, I decided I should pick up the topic here for the Front Porch to bat about. For full disclosure, I’ve never been very satisfied with the sermons from the high priests of nuclear theory. My feelings that something was a bit “off” about how we think about nuclear weapons date back to when I was a Midshipman and the Soviet Union had SSBN patrolling their “Yankee Boxes” in the mid-Atlantic, giving the East Coast of the USA about 10-15-min max to try to find the nearest bomb shelter or confessional. A TIME FOR HERESY With something as existentially important as nuclear weapons, it is only natural that there would be an entire industry of specialists, theorists, and practitioners on the topic. However, there is an uncomfortable arrogance around their untested confidence in their archaic and ravenously expensive concept about the use and utility of nuclear weapons. The high priests in the Nuclear Specialist Guild will brag about “80 years of wargaming and theory” by The Smartest People in the Room™ as if that proves the validity of this, that, or the other idea or scenario to the point that they believe they believe they are entitled to dismiss arguments to the contrary. Bollocks. I’m sorry, no. Nuclear deterrence and war theory are frozen in Aspic from a time that the K Car was going to save Chrysler, and are ripe for a baseline review.. The existential importance of getting as close to “right” as possible demands it. No. No one has "proof" that their pet theory is correct or not—including mine. It is all about opportunity cost, the robustness of your planning assumptions, and where you are willing to accept risk. No one has dropped a nuclear weapon at war in 80 years. As such, this is all theory. My theory of the case is that there is no such thing as “limited nuclear war” between large nuclear powers, or “tactical nuclear weapons.” If I am wrong, then we only have a "limited" nuclear exchange followed by a walk-back and negotiation. If the Neo-McNamarians are wrong in their belief that you can micro-manage your way through a limited nuclear exchange with a major nuclear power, then congrats...you've tripped yourself into a full nuclear exchange that will result in Argentina, New Zealand, and Australia being the major powers on our small planet. Are there certain vignettes that might, might, allow a major nuclear power to have a limited exchange of low yield weapons with small to medium nuclear powers? Sure, I can play that out—though regardless of salesmanship at the Decision Brief, I’m not sure that another U.S. President wants to be known as, “The second U.S. President who conducted a nuclear first strike.” That marker down, you can go ahead and add that to your list of Planning Assumptions: Due mainly to the uncertainty with imperfect intelligence and lack of historical reference points, regardless of public statements to the contrary, no U.S. President will authorize first use of nuclear weapons. In the narrowest of circumstances where something like this needs to be done, it could be handled by nuclear forces designed for peer deterrence either with our existing posture, or the one I offer at the end of the post. Especially at sea, expending time, money, and effort to deploy and maintain a high-overhead, low-probability-of-use weapon system across deployable units is myopic fiscal and strategic foolishness. As a junior officer I saw that up close and personal. No, thank you. THE INERRANCY OF ERRORIt would be helpful if those in the nuclear planning industry recognized how horribly we’ve predicted conventional wars since WWII. We got Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan and even Somalia wrong. With something like nuclear war, are we really confident that the strange people behind the SCIF door will do better? Pulling the "my strategic analysis is unassailable" card by many of the same people who were so wrong on the conventional side is almost as weak as saying, "We have war gamed..." as if that proves anything. That is not what war games are for. We all know that if you tell me what outcome you want, we can design/execute a war game to give you that result. War games are best seen as testing mechanism, not proving mechanisms. KNOW YOUR LEXICONLet’s hit the wave tops of the theory of nuclear war. I find it useful to look at the larger picture as opposed to arguing esoteric and isolated vignettes. Along those lines, there are two major schools of how to conduct nuclear war, counterforce and countervalue. Let’s define our terms, if we can. Not sharing the same definition is where many problems start. It appears that we have been arguing theory and dogma so long without a war to validate any of them, that we have developed a whole constellation of different schools of thought, each with slightly different definitions of the same word. For those looking for a clean and precise definition of terms and concepts, in 2025 you are unlikely to find them. If something so foundational cannot be agreed on, that should give everyone pause in assuming with certitude anything built on top of it. You would think that with this lack of agreement even on terms, responsible players would move towards more flexibility and caution in their assumptions instead of doubling down on their exquisitely assured policy recommendations. You’d think. To explain what I mean by the unstable foundation, what better source would there be than the barely two months old, Counterforce in Contemporary U.S. Nuclear Strategy, edited by Brad Roberts from the Center for Global Security Research at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory? Definitions matter. The new strategic challenge of deterring two peer competitors has revived debates about the benefits and shortcomings of a “counterforce” targeting strategy. That debate reveals the fact that different people have different definitions of the term itself. Thus, their arguments and counterarguments tend not to connect. One result is a general confusion. Another is uncertainty: does “counterforce” actually refer to targets of value to political leaders, nuclear forces including command and control, or military and war-supporting industry? This definitional confusion is particularly important as the United States develops a strategy for deterring two peer competitors, and considerations of counterforce targeting will have implications for deterrence and arms control policies. … In a 2009 essay, for example, Thomas Schelling acknowledged, “We never had an agreed understanding of ‘flexible response’ or ‘nocities’ and its relation to counterforce targeting.” As Acton notes, a counterforce targeting would not necessarily avoid cities. In an attempt to reconcile this false binary, Keir Lieber and Daryl Press advocate for a hybrid of counterforce and countervalue leaving the United States with its current counterforce capabilities to provide credible retaliatory options across a wide range of circumstances (e.g., an adversary’s limited nuclear attack), all the while avoiding the need to build additional counterforce capabilities each time China or Russia enhances its nuclear arsenal. There is an active interplay between the two theories ongoing for decades, but in recent times there are more discussions about how newer capabilities are changing things. One paper in the last half-decade I have significant issues with—mostly because of the antiseptic view it takes of responses to and actions from theory—but I find useful, is Benjamin C. Jamison, Major, USAF’s, The Counterforce Continuum and Tailored Targeting: A New Look at United States Nuclear Targeting Methods and Modern Deterrence: “…if a state is the first to employ nuclear weapons, a counterforce targeting strategy designed as a disarming first strike is the most advantageous approach. In contrast, if the state is responding to a nuclear attack, it ought to use a countervalue targeting strategy as a retaliatory response. While these two approaches have evolved since the Cold War, they remain the foundation of nuclear targeting. With technological advances in the form of precision delivery and low- yield nuclear weapons, and the distinctly different geopolitical climate of 2021 compared to the height of the Cold War, it is time to reevaluate these targeting strategies." It is easy to fall down this rabbit hole and never come back, so let’s pull back a bit from the highly-arguable details and look at the big pixels. As no one will give a short and clear definition of the two largest pillars in the discussion, counterforce and countervalue, I’ll offer my own one sentence shorthand: Counterforce: targeting your enemy’s military capability with the goal of minimizing their ability to continue significant nuclear exchange. Traditional state-on-state warfare, with nuclear characteristics. Countervalue: targeting your enemy’s population centers with the goal of eliminating their population. In essence, a war of annihilation, AKA Tamerlane’s way of war against cities. Do we really know what the doctrine is of any opponent? No. Do we really know what our doctrine will be for each scenario? No. Assume that we have a whole series of war options that span the spectrum—as do our opponents—but you only get one general nuclear war to fight, so what can you expect? Blue and Red have two general options: counterforce and countervalue. Given limited resources and only one chance to play this game, what do you choose? LAST DANCE WITH THE GENIEThe first play only has four options. You really only have two options, because if anyone goes countervalue, the other party will as well. Why? Simple. If the first strike party targets the population (countervalue) at the expense of military targets, then the other party will have a remnant military power that will see the population it is sworn to defend deliberately targeted for genocidal extermination, which is what countervalue is. That party, if they attacked counterforce while their enemy attacked countervalue will have kept additional nuclear weapons in reserve that survived. Thousands of years of human history will tell you what the response will be. Even a mildly successful focused counterforce attack in response to attack will degrade the enemy’s military to the point their remaining population centers will be open for attack. The second strike from the remaining military forces on the receiving end of a countervalue attack will spare no mercy. No quarter should be expected, nor deserved. A dual countervalue attack on the first play will result to both nations’ remaining military forces focused on a mission of mutual genocidal extermination to the last available nuke. You don’t even have to go to ancient examples of this brainstem part of the human condition, just look at the behavior of “modern” Western nations in the mid-19th century Paraguayan War. I am sure that some of you will have an issue with my suggestion that if both parties have a counterforce strategy that someone could “win.” Well, depends on how you define “win,” but yes. If you can keep what is left of your nation intact, even if it is but a shadow of what it was, then you could call it such—but it is a win no one would want. There is also a chance that the nation who does the hard work at peace to make sure their weapons work as needed might have a more effective strike could come out on tope because the other the nation’s military lied and faked performance of its strategic systems at peace and was plagued by failures and inaccuracies. The United States could lose 70% of its population and still have a bit over 100 million souls. That is a nation. A starving and sick nation, but a nation nonetheless. That’s little solace, as you’d have hundreds of millions dead, your economy destroyed, and your land polluted for centuries. This leads to a point not discussed enough: all four possible outcomes have severe global consequences. Regardless of the combination of NATO-RUSSIA-CHINA-USA in a peer nuclear exchange along the lines above, independent of the devastation in the nations involved in the exchange, it is the rest of the world where most of the dying will take place. Russia, China, and North America are the world’s breadbaskets. Without the free flow of agricultural goods, both raw foodstuffs and fertilizer, the human population cannot feed itself. Even if agriculture was not disrupted, the radiation will make the food that is harvested, unmarketable for years to centuries. A few nations in the Southern Hemisphere might be able to produce contamination free food to satisfy their local needs, but nothing for export. We will see in the years that follow any general nuclear exchange in the northern hemisphere, global starvation to a degree never seen. Most of Africa, the Middle East, and especially South Asia will be nightmares few can imagine. Will it be the end of mankind? No. As a species, we have survived worse, but human civilization will enter a new era no one today can quite define. What I am willing to say, like I did earlier, is that modern civilization will be led by Australia, New Zealand, Argentina. Maybe Chile too. Brazil will try, but she can never get out of her way. The best way to prevent a general nuclear exchange is to deter it from taking place. However, if history delivers it at your feet even if you try to avoid it, shouldn’t you at least try to have a chance, however small, of coming out of it in one piece? In light of the above, what should we be investing in? 21st CENTURY NUCLEAR FORCERight now we have the ICBM, SSBN, and manned bomber as our strategic deterrence, AKA The Triad. The Triad is an inertia-based holdover of the Eisenhower Era that ended almost a decade before I was born, and the contest with the Soviet Union that ended when I was a LTjg. It is 2025, not 1975. We don’t wear the same clothes, nor should we approach nuclear theory the same way either. There are better alternatives, and I’ll outline one below. As we find in many areas, due to delays and general poor stewardship of our nuclear forces for the last decade—always pushing decisions to the right—recapitalization of our nuclear deterrence force is in crisis. Our present Triad? Let’s be blunt about what our inheritance is in 2025. ICBM: The Minuteman III Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles are as geriatric in theory as their support systems are in practice. Its replacement, the Sentinel, is not shockingly late and overbudget. SSBN: Heck, I’ve been warning of this problem since 2010, but our youngest Ohio Class SSBN is 28 years old. The oldest four were converted to SSGN, leaving 14 SSBN. Its replacement, the dozen Columbia Class SSBN, besides having 4 fewer missiles as it was designed during a different strategic situation, is expected to be ready in 2031. Bombers: On a good day, we might have a dozen fully mission capable B-2 bombers. Probably less. The B-1 bombers are conventional only and the B-52 cannot survive anywhere near contested air—relegated to stand off nuclear weapons and/or suicide missions. Of course, as also have nuclear gravity bombs that TACAIR fighters like the F-35 can carry. In 2025, they are the nuclear equivalent to the bayonet. If you have to use it, you are in trouble. You don’t lead an attack with it, and by the time it becomes an option, you are surrounded with death and gore. It is comfortable to have in your kit, “just in case” - but it won’t decide wars. The greatest use that gravity bombs serve is the nuclear equivalent of a security blanket for our allies. NATO gravity bombs are a signaling device that convince the Germans, Poles or anyone else that, really, they don’t need to build their own nukes. Should the ballon go up, they won’t be of much use, especially in Europe. If they survive a first strike, and if they ever receive the authorization to strike themselves, by the time they reach their targets—if they reach their targets—much of the exchange will be over and their one way trip—as there will be no refueling aircraft available on the trip home—will be mostly in vain. So, that is what we have. What should we invest in the future? ICBM: Let’s be clear, ICBM in 2025 is a first strike weapon. We have them because we have them because we have them, all 400 single-warhead of them. Are they really a deterrence worth the cost and investment? No. Are they of any use besides an age-ending first-use nuclear exchange? No. Can their age-ending effects and deterrence be done by other more survivable yet equally effective platforms? Yes. The ICBM leg of The Triad served our nation well, but is no longer the best tool to achieve the deterrence we desire. We can sundown our nuclear ICBM with no impact on strategic defense. As a pleasant side effect—we could move on to the more useful and needed conventionally armed ballistic missile arena without other powers wondering if we launch one if it has a nuclear warhead. SSBN: The Ohio can, in theory, carry 20 SLBM (though built to carry 24), the Columbia 16. They can have a MIRV’d warhead. Once underway, they are the most survivable part of the present Triad, and they are just as accurate as ICBM. We can, and should, build more to cover the targeting gap left by the ICBM force. Create a Flight II Columbia Class with that can carry 20 missiles if that is what is needed. We can get that additional funding from the decommissioning of the obsolete ICBM force. Bombers: These are the most useful of the deterrence force as they are dual use. With the B-21 ready for serial production, we should build a lot more of them than we plan too. As we learned (again) earlier this month, they don’t have to wait for the end of the world to be used. They are a solid investment due to their flexibility more than anything else. Let’s make sure the nuclear armed AGM-181A Long-Range Standoff cruise missile is a success as well. Others: Gravity Bombs: As outlined above, like the bayonet, they have a use or two, but should not be relied on as a primary tool SLCM-N: I’ve made my feelings about SLCM-N known last October. I won’t repeat them here. Executive Summary: not just no, he11 no. In crisis is opportunity. We can maintain nuclear deterrence while at the same time streamlining, simplifying, and maybe even freeing up funds for the most likely fight—a conventional one primarily in the sea and air west of the International Date Line. If we do this right, we can help keep the nuclear genie in its bottle. If we let the intellectual blob continue as if nothing has changed for decades, we not only will increase costs, we will decrease deterrence…and with that, increase the odds of a war no one wants. Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Non-State Special Operations, with Craig Whiteside & Ian Rice - on Midrats
On today’s Midrats, we have returning guest Craig Whiteside and his co-author Ian C. Rice joining us to discuss one of the nightmares we all have in the new book coming out this month. He co-authored it with Ian Rice, Non-state Special Operations: Capabilities and Effects. From the abstract: Building on previous research on Islamic State special operations, the book develops a theoretical framework surrounding a typology of VNSA (militants, proxies, criminal/cults, and mercenaries) to explore variations of non-state special operations, with multiple cases for each category of actor. Understanding when and why VNSA use special operations provides insights into the inner workings of such groups and how they campaign, and also has implications for the proliferation of special operation forces around the globe and its influence on non-state behaviour. This volume contributes to research on the recent trend of non-state actors surprising, and in some cases humiliating, their state opponents. You can listen at this link or via the Spotify widget below. Craig is Professor of National Security Affairs at the US Naval War College resident program at the Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California. He is the co-author of The ISIS Reader: Milestone Texts of the Islamic State Movement (2020). He has a PhD in Political Science from Washington State University and is a former U.S. Army infantry officer. His coauthor Ian is an adjunct Senior Lecturer in the Department of Defense Analysis, Naval Postgraduate School, adjunct faculty member with the College of Distance Education, USMC University, and a guest lecturer with the Royal Danish Defence College. He is a retired U.S. Army officer who served with special operations forces. Show LinksNon-state Special Operations: Capabilities and Effects, by Craig Whiteside and Ian Rice. Operation Chariot Defeat Into Victory: Battling Japan in Burma and India, 1942-1945, Field-Marshal Viscount William Slim SummaryIn this episode of Midrats, hosts discuss the complexities of non-state special operations with authors Craig Whiteside and Ian Rice. They delve into the historical context, defining characteristics, and implications of special operations conducted by non-state actors. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding the motivations and strategies of these actors, as well as the challenges they pose to state actors. The authors share insights from their new book, exploring the evolution of non-state operations and the need for a nuanced approach to countering them. TakeawaysSpecial operations are defined as tactical actions designed to achieve outsized effects. Historical examples illustrate the long-standing use of special operations by non-state actors. Understanding the typology of non-state actors is crucial for effective analysis and response. Prison breakouts are a common tactic used by non-state actors to regain manpower. Cults and criminal groups can also engage in special operations, often driven by self-interest. Not all terrorist acts qualify as special operations; criteria must be applied to distinguish them. The opportunity cost of special operations can be significant for both state and non-state actors. Mercenaries have a unique role in conducting special operations, particularly in coups. Chapters00:00: Introduction to Non-State Special Operations 02:15: Genesis of the Book and Collaboration 05:49: Defining Special Operations 08:43: Historical Context of Non-State Actors 11:36: Analyzing Non-State Actors 18:13: Understanding the Typology of Non-State Actors 23:42: Criteria for Special Operations 28:45: Prison Breakouts as a Tactic 32:13: Cults and Criminal Groups in Special Operations 36:53: Distinguishing Terrorism from Special Operations 43:26: The Cost of Special Operations 49:13: Mercenaries and Coups 52:08: Mindset of Special Operations 58:47Implications for Future Operations Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Fullbore Friday
When it comes to the A-1H Skyraider vs. MiG-17s, some are familiar with the story from 1966, but have you heard it first person right after it took place? This story, which I first covered back in 2009, is a classic and brings us back to a man we honored in another FbF last month: Lieutenant Pete Russell, USN. That’s him on the right in the picture above, with LTJg. Tom Patton, USN as they discuss the story below. LCDR Leo Cook and his wingman LTJG Wiley were the lead section of Skyraiders working to locate and hopefully rescue a downed US pilot in North Vietnam. While maneuvering at low altitude between ridges and cloud layers, they were jumped by what turned out to be two sections of MiG 17s. Calling out the attack on their common radio frequency, Cook and Wiley fought for their lives. LT Pete Russell and LTJG Tom Patton soon arrived in the area and immediately gained a position of advantage on the MiGs. The details of this encounter were taped by the intelligence officer on board the Intrepid after the incident. You can listen to the interview conducted by LTjg Bill Morgan, USN, the Public Affairs Officer of the USS Intrepid (CV-11) in the Gulf of Tonkin in October of 1966, below. (NB: the aircraft in question are from VA-176, not VA174.) Taking on jets with your prop-job? That is in the finest traditions of the naval service, and fullbore. Share Leave a comment This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - I Have Our Next Cruiser, if You're Smart Enough to Take it
On Monday, the Congressional Research Service came out with its latest, Navy DDG(X) Next-Generation Destroyer Program: Background and Issues for Congress. This is worth your time, as we need to get this right. We have to get this right because we have yet to cut steel on a successfully designed surface warship since Ronaldus Magnus was CINC. The same organizations, processes—and in some cases people—that failed on DDG-1000, LCS, CG(X), and are doing their best to scupper FFG-62, are working on DDG(X), so keep a weather eye on the program. I’m trying to be an optimist, but concerns have been growing roots for years. Low-trust is well-deserved. At first read, I thought we had some good news. If you can judge by the picture in the report, contrary to the concerns I had in January, it looked like the general purpose 5” main gun is back, but note the source…they’re using Sam’s January 2024 image. The image from my January linked to above is newer…so…yeah. Sigh. Also, no gun is mentioned in the report…in spite of every actual combat experience of the post-WWII naval combat—especially the last few years in the Red Sea—show the absolute essential nature of the general purpose gun in real world combat situations…but let’s move on. Let’s review some basics from the report for new readers, The Navy states that the baseline DDG(X) design, like the Fight III DDG-51 design, is to include 96 standard Vertical Launch System (VLS) cells, with an ability to incorporate 12 large missile launch cells in place of 32 of the 96 standard VLS cells. It is also to include two 21-cell Rolling Airframe Missile (RAM) launchers, and possibly also an ability to be built with an additional mid-body hull section, called the Destroyer Payload Module, that would provide additional payload capacity. The Navy states that Note the bold underline I added to the above. I’ll get back to that at the end of today’s post. In the same paragraph, they share the respectful but simple truth of the great Cold War (modified) Burkes. …the requirement for future large surface combatants (LSCs) to be capable of hosting directed energy (DE) weapons, larger missiles for increased range and speed, increased magazine depth, growth in organic sensors, and an efficient integrated power system to manage the dynamic loads. DDG 51 is highly capable, but after over 40 years in production and 30 years of upgrades the hull form does not provide sufficient space and center of gravity margin to host future capabilities. … studies concluded that DDG(X) is required to deliver the necessary margins and flexibility to succeed the DDG 51 Class as the next enduring LSC combining the DDG 51 FLT III combat system elements with new hull form, an efficient Integrated Power System (IPS) and greater endurance, reducing the Fleet logistics burden.... We’ve reached the limits of her design. So far, aligning with Salamander direction and guidance about minimizing technology and program risk as much as possible so to not create FORD CVN type problems…but, what about the IPS? Oh, no. The Navy plans to model the IPS at a land-based test site, but the results may not be available to fully inform the ship’s design prior to detailed design. The second critical technology is the ship’s hull form. The program continues to conduct risk reduction activities for both critical technologies. OK, full stop. What part of the ship’s design is driven by the go-nogo of IPS? Have we learned nothing? As IPS is what will make or break the entire concept of DDG(X) as it is being put forward, it is gobsmacking we still don’t know if it can work. We should put everything else that relies on its performance on hold and throw money at the IPS testing site, figure out how to make it happen, and then pick things up from there. We cannot, again, start cutting steel on an incomplete design. LCS/NLOS, FREMM-to-FFG-62, and other similar goat-ropes the last few decades should explain to everyone why the program should go tools-down until we know if IPS is a go. I think that is clear. Now, let’s look at the “Issues for Congress.” (1) Would a new LSC larger than the Flight III DDG-51 design be consistent with the Navy’s desire to shift to a more distributed fleet architecture that includes a larger number of smaller ships? (2) The Navy in the past has studied options for a lengthened version of the DDG-51 design. Would the DDG(X) be more cost-effective than a lengthened DDG-51? (3) Has the Navy accurately identified the DDG(X)’s required operational capabilities? (4) Why is there a 33% difference between the CBO and Navy estimates of the DDG(X)’s average procurement cost? (5) Would future Navy budgets permit the procurement of DDG(X)s in desired numbers while adequately funding other Navy priorities? (6) Is the Navy taking adequate steps to mitigate technical, schedule, and cost risk in the program? (7) Is the Navy planning adequately for the transition from DDG-51 procurement to DDG(X) procurement? Let me try to answer these, in order. Yes, as a balanced fleet requires large surface combatants, destroyers and cruisers, and smaller warships like frigates. We are morphing our FFG into a DDLG, so … build both. As much as I would enjoy my prophecy that we will build Arleigh Burke DDG until the crack-of-doom to be made true, really the hull has done its duty. We need to advance. You cannot predict the future. If anything, recent history tells us we are bad at even trying. I doubt the “requirements” are all that valid. Heck, these are the people who expected us to believe the 57mm for FFG-62 was based on anything but the most base Beltway blobish slimy reasons. Build for flexibility so our Navy can adjust as the future reveals itself. Because no one really knows. Just assume the higher estimate is closer. Only if we fundamentally change how we allocate the defense budget. No. They haven’t yet, and without firm, hard, and direct leadership—it will repeat the same mistakes because we are using the same system, programs, processes, and people who bought this century’s shipbuilding debacles. I doubt it. We have not done so in decades. Let’s go back to the opening of the paragraph quoted above about IPS from the June 2025 GAO report, The Navy approved changes to the operational requirements for the [DDG(X)] program in August 2024. The program is assessing how the changes affect its schedule and cost estimates and officials did not provide a time frame for when they will update these estimates. OK. Stop. No more letting this guy in the room. Freeze the design. Tell the Good Idea Fairy that time is up. Let’s make sure IPS works, and then start to cut steel. Again, authorize and build more Burkes for a few years until testing is done if that is what is needed. We could always use more. We can’t screw DDG(X) up. We can start by giving the class a proper name, for starters. I have a suggestion, rename the expected DDG-141 and take that name and make it the first ship in the class, USS Ernest E. Evans (DDG-XX). While we are at it, we can rename the also authorized but not yet started Danzig, Mullen, and Mabus. Now, let’s return to the bold italics at the top of the post. In my SEPT 2022 Substack on DDG(X) I stated the following, PS: we still need a cruiser. How do we do that? A successful path to the future is to follow the successes of the past. The Ticonderoga class, using the highly successful Spruance hull, … The greater size and equipment on the CG-47-class cruisers increased displacement from 6,900 tons of the DD-963-class destroyers to 9,600 tons of displacement for the heavier cruisers. …and what did we highlight from Monday’s CRS report? possibly also an ability to be built with an additional mid-body hull section, called the Destroyer Payload Module Bollocks to “possibly”—no, grab a multi-generational design team and tell them, “This ‘Destroyer Payload Module’ is the ‘cruiser module’. We’re building a CG-74 Class cruiser in parallel with the DDG(X). At least for Flight I of this new cruiser, that module will be dedicated to air and space defense weapons. I want people to need an abacus to count the number of VLS cells. Throw in additional space for it to be a flagship if needed. Get to work. Don't argue the matter. The difficulties will argue for themselves.” More. Faster. Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - The Three Amigos of WESTPAC
It has taken a while, mostly because of the memories of their grandfathers, but after years of hard work by people you may never hear of, one of the most powerful, important, and natural alliances in the Pacific is growing closer together—that of Japan, Australia, and the U.S. Senior U.S., Australian and Japanese flag officers agreed today to further enhance logistics interoperability among their maritime forces. Their intent is to enable deeper maritime cooperation among the three nations, building upon their enduring commitment to stability and security in the Indo-Pacific. Official seal of the Department of the Navy. Note: 18 United States Code, Part 1, Chapter 47, Section 1017, prohibits the use of this Department of the Navy seal by anyone other than bona fide commands and activities of the Department of the Navy and the Department of Defense where appropriate. Secretary of the Navy Instruction 5030.4A of 17 March 1986 restricts the use of this Department of the Navy seal to official use only and to the exclusive use of the Department of the Navy and the Department of Defense. Vice Adm. Jeff Jablon (Deputy Chief of Naval Operations for Installations and Logistics, OPNAV N4), Rear Adm. Naoya Hoshi (Director General of Logistics Department, Maritime Staff Office, Japan Maritime Self Defense Force (JMSDF)), and Commodore Catherine Rhodes (Director General Logistics, Royal Australian Navy (RAN)) took part in the signing ceremony aboard USS America (LHA-6) during a port visit in Brisbane. This is a solid starting point for what I hope is a closer integration of training and planning between the three friends. Japan and Australia may not have a mutual defense treaty, yet, they do have the Japan-Australia Reciprocal Access Agreement, and they both have a mutual defense treaty with the U.S., making us the tie together. Logistics—the most challenging and critical foundation of any war in the Pacific, lays a strong foundation for cooperation in further warfare areas. “Sustainment in depth is a primary objective,” said Vice Adm. Jablon. “We have robust logistics partnerships with Japan and Australia to ensure we can provide the right material and services at the right place, at the right time to mutually support our maritime forces, from day-to-day training during peacetime through contingencies. This arrangement strengthens those commitments and allows us to more easily share information, technologies and processes for greater logistics resiliency.” Reloading missile systems and flexible refueling are among the areas of cooperation outlined in the agreement. This is all just plain good stuff. “Japan is excited about the chance to collaborate more closely with our U.S. and Australian partners,” said Rear Adm. Hoshi. “This new arrangement will allow us to broaden the scope and increase the efficiency of our interactions.” Beyond information and technology sharing through these types of agreements, incorporating logistics activities into training in a realistic manner remains a focus area for U.S. naval forces. Examples include offloading missiles from dry cargo/ammunition ships, rearming cruisers and destroyers, refueling at sea, ship and aircraft repair, airfield damage repair, salvage operations, and medical evacuations. The signing took place just prior to the official kickoff of exercise Talisman-Sabre 2025, during which Australia, Japan, and other partners will participate in many of these activities as feasible. “During Talisman-Sabre and beyond, we have clear opportunities to work trilaterally with our U.S. and Japanese partners on logistics initiatives,” said Commodore Rhodes. “These efforts facilitate our speed of response for the full range of naval actions in the Indo-Pacific, from routine sustainment through crisis.” Whatever needs to be done to expand such trilateral gatherings should be given the highest priority. The press release is good, but the WSJ has a nice companion piece on the topic. In the rugged hills outside this coastal city, Japanese and Australian artillery crews fired in tandem on a distant target. They were assisted by U.S. Marines, who were embedded with the Australian gun teams. The live-fire drill was the culmination of Southern Jackaroo, an expanding annual exercise in the Australian bush in which the three nations’ forces practice working together as allies. Although top officers didn’t call out any foe by name, troops taking part said it was clear that they were training to fight China. … Australia and Japan, both of which have security pacts with the U.S., have emerged as essential U.S. partners in the Pacific. If a war were to erupt, Washington would want Tokyo to sign off on the U.S. using its Japanese bases to confront China and for Australia to send aircraft, ships and troops to Japan to help the fight, some defense analysts say. “If there’s any argument to be made for a collective approach to deterrence in the region, it’s these three countries,” said Jeffrey Hornung, the Japan lead at Rand, a think tank. This is a good time to remember that in spite of all our challenges and missteps, we have a comparative advantage against the People’s Republic of China (PRC), if we properly tend to it and maintain stewardship of the better parts of our inheritance. Japan, Australia, and the U.S. have friends and allies—the PRC has proxies, clients, and subjects. In their 2025 Defense of Japan White Paper, the Japanese Ministry of Defense put it well, The international community is now facing its greatest trial since the end of World War II. The existing order of world peace is being seriously challenged, and Japan finds itself in the most severe and complex security environment of the post-war era. It’s good to have friends at such times. These three democratic nations’ strategic interests in the Pacific align so closely that friction on key issues is rare. All gain by peace and stability, none desire conflict, all face a growing autocratic power that has eyes on either their submission or compliant indifference. Smaller powers look to all three for support as they too try to avoid the demands of the covetous power that is the People’s Republic of China. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Share Leave a comment View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - In the Red Sea, Don't Bring a Gun to a Missile Fight
Few people in the maritime space have been thinking, writing, and speaking about counter-piracy more than our friend Claude Berube. As a matter of fact, we discussed just this topic in Episode 2 of the Midrats Podcast back in January of 2010. You can access the audio from the Episode, with the late, great Raymond Pritchard as one of the co-hosts, at this link. He was on a roll that year, the following month he was on a great panel at Heritage that, sadly, is no longer available on the internet. In 2012, my Midrats co-host wrote a nice article about a superb collection he co-edited, Maritime Private Security: Market responses to piracy, terrorism and waterborne security risks in the 21st century. So, when Claude brings up the topic of piracy and lawlessness on the high seas, the best bet is to stop what you’re doing and give him a read—even his novels that tie in the subject. Fast forward a decade and a half, over at his Substack on Saturday, he brought up some spot-on commentary on some of the latest news out of the Red Sea. Not all the outlaws on the high seas are the same…even when they are in the same neighborhood. The recent attack on the Eternity C that left crew members dead, kidnapped, or missing and the ship itself on the seafloor was more than another statistic in the Red Sea. For a professional perspective on the entire incident, check Sal Mercogliano’s youtube. I want to focus on a particular aspect - that armed guards were aboard. Among those caught up in the chaos were guards from Ambrey, the world’s largest private maritime security company. … The arrival of private security teams on merchant ships - and in some rarer cases a few companies that offered ships as security escorts - was effective enough that by the mid-2010s Somali piracy was largely under control. For years, that model held. The threat posed by Houthis, however, changes that model. … But the Houthis are not pirates. They’re not motivated by money but by politics. They’re less interested in capturing a ship than in the high-value publicity that a sinking ship offers to their cause. Along the lines of my call at the end of last year to, Arm the Auxiliaries, is it time to, What tools or commercially-available weapons be available to private maritime security companies to counter the Houthi threat. To be honest, I don’t know. I have some thoughts on some technologies but each time I look at it, there’s a cost associated the more complex a solution you find. And with those costs, shipping companies will weigh if it is simply more cost-effective to circumnavigate Africa (itself not so inexpensive) rather than risk a ship transiting the Red Sea conducting legitimate commerce. We’ve already seen changes during the Somali piracy era changed the cost of doing business as well as private security options. No, that isn’t the answer. You know what is an answer? What is your use of your navy if you cannot protect your own merchants? The better answer is state-sponsored counter-measures to protect that commerce. That has been the traditional role of navies, and the US Navy has recent experience responding to the Houthi threat. But the US, under current limitations, cannot be the region’s only guarantor of legitimate maritime commerce. What worked in the Gulf of Aden in 2011 won’t work in the Red Sea in 2025. Flexibility, good intelligence, and a commitment to protecting those at sea are still essential, but the playbook needs to change. If the last fifteen years were about putting armed guards on deck, the next fifteen will be about rethinking what security at sea really means - and who’s responsible for providing it. There’s the nub. The nations that most like to talk about the “international order” seem to have a toxic combination of the lack of will to move beyond talk, and even when they do take action, lack the capacity or even capability. There should be an international answer, but if the only suitable option is the Chinese CONOPS or the European close escort operation, then that will be it. A reason for the lack of an international solution might be simple. An international solution would require U.S. Navy leadership. The U.S. Navy would prefer aggressive Rules of Engagement (ROE). However, European navies might impose restrictive national caveats and ROE. The U.S. could risk conflicts with Iran. Additionally, U.S. actions might be seen as supporting Israel, which many wish to avoid. Thus, we’re left with Operation Hodgepodge. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Share Leave a comment View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - The Big Defense Budgets are not Coming
Take a deep breath, relax, focus, and we’ll get through this together. We don’t have to like what is in front of us, but we do have to accept that it is there. I try to be optimistic, but I’m also a realist. You have what you have, and you have to be an adult about what is placed in front of you. I told you a decade and a half ago, The Terrible 20s were coming. You can only hold back the flood for so long. Math is hard and does not have feelings. Don’t put too much stock in what is said. Look at what is being done. Though most NATO allies have agreed to spend 5% of their GDP on defense, absent a major war, it’s unlikely to happen except in a very few places like perhaps Poland or one of the Baltic republics. They won’t do it because they promised the USA, they will do it because they believe it is in their interest to do so. You see, in 2025, it is expected that the USA won’t even break 3% of GDP on defense. We will probably wind up just at 2.9%. If Uncle Sam isn’t going to break 3%, I don’t see our allies stretching for 5%. We would be lucky if they match us, and we’re drifting to 2.5%. More and more people are starting to see this and speak about it openly. Even The Wall Street Journal Editorial Page is going Salamander. The White House is touting its $1 trillion defense budget for 2026. Mr. Trump has also taken a deserved bow for getting NATO to agree to spend 5% of GDP on defense. But the U.S. isn’t meeting that NATO target. It’s spending roughly half the 6% of GDP it devoted to defense at the height of Ronald Reagan’s military buildup. Even the $1 trillion is a game of three-card monte. The Administration counts in that total about $113 billion for defense in the GOP’s budget reconciliation bill. That money was supposed to turbocharge purchases of ships, aircraft and unmanned technology—above normal defense spending. Yet when the budget bill is excluded, the Administration has proposed a cut after inflation for 2026. Absent more annual GOP bills, which may not be possible if Republicans lose Congress, defense spending could fall to about 2.65% of the economy by 2029 at the end of Mr. Trump’s term. That’s comparable to the European levels that Mr. Trump thinks are so pathetic. Yes, yes, yes…I fully understand the budget bill trick of 2025…that is nice, but it what it is, a trick. It will work for a year—but it does not underscore a baseline. Will the budget battle in an election year match it? The money trick of 2025 delays the hard decisions and the very adult conversation we need to have about how we allocate our budget to best prepare for the expected fight west of the International Date Line—a fight that will be a maritime and aerospace fight. Take shipbuilding. The 2026 request asks for a mere three U.S. Navy ships, though the fleet is 60 short of its goal to deter China. Funding for 16 more ships is included in the GOP budget bill. But no contractor puts up long-term capital to expand production for a one-year plan. Unstable demand from government helped produce the current shipbuilding crisis. Mr. Trump cares about restoring U.S. naval power, but what matters is the scoreboard. America needs to build 2.33 attack submarines a year to meet our own requirements and a commitment to sell hulls to the Australians. The current rate is 1.1. This problem did not creep up overnight. It has been “appreciated” since I wrote the piece linked to above from April of 2010. As you’ll see on the graph at the bottom of the post, we have accepted a bipartisan serial lie we have told to ourselves to make us feel better about “today”, and letting the hard reality of “tomorrow” be someone else’s problem. Well, Shipmate, “tomorrow” is today. The budget pours $3.5 billion into the new F-47 fighter jet, which is needed. Yet F-35 buys are cut to 47 from 74, and a new fighter for the U.S. Navy is on hold. The latter is especially absurd: U.S. aircraft carrier vulnerability in the Pacific is the most discussed military weakness of the decade, and longer-range aircraft on carriers would be a big counter. Mr. Trump likes to invoke Reagan’s peace through strength worldview. But the Gipper made a sustained case about the threats the U.S. faced and the forces required to keep the peace. He explicitly rejected making “defense once again the scapegoat of the federal budget.” The threats to U.S. security today are arguably greater than during the Cold War: A peer competitor in China, an imperial Russia, the risk of proliferating nuclear weapons, and new technology that empowers lesser powers and threatens the U.S. homeland. Congress can fill some of the Trump defense potholes, but reinvigorating the U.S. military requires White House leadership. It would be helpful to note that we are only six months into the Trump second term. He still does not have his full team in place. People are being put in place who are want to attack this challenge, but they are only part of the team and are still getting their footing. That “excuse” is running out of time, however. Once Labor Day gets here, it won’t work anymore. What they need is money, attention, and top-cover. In a world in a frenetic crisis quickening, attention will be hard to get. Without that, you won’t have the money. With no attention or money, you won’t get top-cover because you won’t even be noticed. No one said it would be simple or easy. The President’s party in Congress has comically narrow majority in both chambers. What should be a bipartisan effort to secure our nation’s defense against a rising power is instead being held hostage to…what exactly? Institutional inertia, petty party politics, and programmatic entitlement? On the Navy side, with Executive and Legislative Branch working together, you can fix shipbuilding. There are companies and entrepreneurs who are standing by to make this happen. All it takes is a consistent demand signal, accountable leadership, and political will. As the below shows, our Culture of Untruth™ consistently results in over-promise and under-delivery. I mean, just look at it. Are you satisfied with our people? Proud of our process? Want to emulate our leadership in building our fleet? Which nation’s fleet is being built to fight and win at sea, and which nation’s fleet is inviting humiliation and crisis for the nation it serves? h/t Steve.This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Share Leave a comment View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - The Power & Spirit of Camp David - on Midrats
Take a break from the heat today to discuss some of the hidden history, and importance, of the Presidential retreat at Camp David with the author of the book, Presidential Seclusion: The Power of Camp David, Charles Ferguson. You can listen at this link, or with the Spotify widget below. After graduating from Georgia Tech and earning his commission, Charles Ferguson served for 11 years in the Submarine force onboard the USS Louisville and as Weapons Officer onboard USS Buffalo with a shore duty at Nuclear Power School in between. He switched to the IRR as Chaplain Candidate while attending seminary at Duke Divinity School and was recommissioned as an Active Duty Chaplain in 2010. As a chaplain he has served with both Navy and Marine Corps commands to include three and a half years as the Chaplain and Historian at Camp David. ShowlinkPresidential Seclusion: The Power of Camp David SummaryThis conversation explores the historical significance and operational dynamics of the Presidential retreat of Camp David. The discussion highlights its origins, the Navy's role in its management, and the unique environment it provides for presidents to make critical decisions. The conversation also delves into the architectural design that facilitates diplomacy, notable guests who have visited, and the personal touches each president has added to the retreat. Additionally, the role of the chaplain and the supportive relationship with the local community are examined, emphasizing the importance of solitude for leaders in high-pressure positions. Chapters00:00: Introduction to Camp David's Significance 05:35: The Navy's Role in Camp David's History 10:27: Becoming the Chaplain and Historian at Camp David 15:22: The Origins and Transformation of Camp David 20:38: The Impact of Camp David on Presidential Decisions 29:15: Notable Guests and Diplomatic Encounters at Camp David 30:53: Architectural Diplomacy at Camp David 34:20: Presidential Modifications and Personal Touches 38:04: The Origin of Camp David's Name 40:58: Management and Operations at Camp David 43:13: The Role of the Chaplain 45:25: The Solitude of Leadership 49:32: Community Interactions and Local Support 53:22: Memorable Moments and Staff Contributions 58:14: The Importance of Setting Conditions for Peace 01:00: Future Projects and Closing Thoughts Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Fullbore Friday
Whenever you walk around base, you may not be aware that—should fate call them—you are passing holders of Medal of Honor, Navy Cross and other heroes. Sure, they don’t have it now, but should circumstances allow—their true character will be revealed. When you join the service, you have no idea what will find you in the course of your service, or when just another boring duty day turns into something immortal. In the horrible tragedy over the weekend in Texas, we saw an example of this in the person of USCG rescue swimmer, Petty Officer Third Class Scott Ruskan. Via USA Today’s Lori Comstock Ruskan, a U.S. Coast Guard rescue swimmer from Oxford, New Jersey, is being credited with saving 165 kids and camp counselors from Camp Mystic, an all-girls Christian camp where around 200 children were trapped by rising flood waters. … Petty Officer 3rd Class Scott Ruskan is a U.S. Coast Guard rescue swimmer from Oxford Township in Warren County. He earned a bachelor's degree in accounting, with a minor in Homeland Security Policy, from Rider University in 2021, according to his LinkedIn page. He is a 2017 graduate of Warren Hills High School, who recognized their alumnus in a Facebook post. … Ruskan has been stationed at US Coast Guard Station Corpus Christi, about 210 miles from Kerrville in central Texas, where the Guadalupe River flooded its banks. He told GMA it took nearly six hours to reach the flood zone due to the weather, and once he landed, he was the only certified rescue swimmer on scene at Camp Mystic. The humble professional. "I just happened to be on the duty crew," the 26-year-old New Jersey native said … "I kind of discovered I was the only person there as far as first responders go. So I had about 200, kids mostly. All scared, terrified, cold, having probably the worst day of their life. And I just kind of needed to triage them, get them to a higher level of care and get 'em off the flood zone." The heroic first responder worked alongside members of the United States Army National Guard to get the people loaded and to safety. "We kind of came up with two different landing zones. There was one off an archery field and then one in a soccer field. We were able to kind of land those 60s [rescue helicopters] in there. I was kind of the main guy as far as grabbing people," he said. … "I really just kind of relied on the training we get. Coast Guard rescue swimmers get some of the highest level training in the world. So really just kind of relied on that, just knowing that any of the rescue swimmers in the Coast Guard would have done the exact same if not better than me," he said. He was also bolstered by the children on the scene, who he knew were relying on his skills. "They don't really know what my experience is or my rank or my age," he said. "They just know, 'Hey this guy is a professional, and he's here to help us.' And I kind of had to live up to that standard." BZ Scott. BZ. In his own words. Share Leave a comment This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Old and Busted: Phat MK-48--New Hotness: MK-58?
OK, hold on…you might have suffered the same yawn that I did when reading news about our old girl NIXIE… U.S. Navy budget documentation released last week is adding a series of new capabilities to the current AN/SLQ-25 Nixie countermeasures suite, including a new hard-kill capability via deck launchers, set to be deployed to over 168 different front-line ships in coming years. …until you got to the second clause. I know some of you are thinking, “Oh, we can talk about hard kill now?” Then, in the next paragraph by Carter Johnson at Naval News, this sexy little creature wanders on stage, The hard-kill weapon, known as the Mk58 Compact Rapid Attack Weapon (CRAW), is expected to be deployed on Nimitz and Ford-class aircraft carriers initially, supplementing the Nixie’s soft-kill capability with a proven hard-kill capability that is currently deployed on attack submarines. The plan comes after years of development and experimentation with different sensors, weapons, and configurations. The what? Of course, we need to pull the thread on this, The War Zone reported on first signs of an ATT CRAW variant in 2020, while ideas of a general counter-torpedo torpedo, in the form of the Countermeasure Anti-Torpedo (CAT), date back even further. The U.S. Navy shifted CAT sustainment in FY2024 when it merged the developed equipment and procedures into the CRAW program. This time the Navy is confident that the ATT CRAW and associated hardware within Nixie are mature enough to deploy across the fleet. What does this little lady look like? “CRAW TI-1 effort acquisition strategy is to fund Penn State University Applied Research Laboratory (PSU-ARL) to complete modification of the existing very-lightweight torpedo design leveraged from the ATTDS program. The CRAW TI-1 effort is being executed as a Middle Tier of Acquisition (MTA) effort and will rapidly develop fieldable prototypes to demonstrate the new very-lightweight torpedo ASW capabilities in an operational environment.” This will give you a little better perspective about its size. Wait, let’s go back up a bit, did I read that correctly…you can deploy this on USV…that means you can put it about anywhere, including riverine boats? But wait, it just gets better. “Revolver is a launcher integration kit that is required to integrate the MK 58 [CRAW] torpedo into the [Virginia-class] submarine Torpedo Tubes. The Revolver system is not permanently installed onto the submarine. Instead it is loaded onto the submarine in the same manner as any payload that is stowed in the torpedo room.” U.S. Navy FY2026 Budget Documentation … TI-1 is also driving development of the Revolver MP and Reloader, as well as capabilities to launch torpedoes from vertical launch cells equipped on Virginia-class attack submarines. CRAW torpedoes developed under TI-1 will remain in the fleet as a residual operational capability, and TI-2 will become the main torpedo of choice in the CRAW family. TI-2, Raytheon-led, will improve on TI-1 to improve mass production potential while adding additional capabilities to the weapon, like counter-torpedo capability for both submarines and surface ships. … The Mk 58 CRAW torpedo is slated to become a workhorse of the U.S. Navy by 2030, in a move that will change how submarines and surface combatants can engage and defend against a variety of high-end and low-end targets. The Mk 58 offers magazine depth in the dozens for low-cost, high-density, large-salvo missions against large and small surface ships—something INDOPACOM sees as favorable to engage hostile amphibious forces in constrained, littoral areas of the Pacific. Basically, trading off some range, speed, and payload, we will have more, cheaper, that will have anti-torpedo, anti-submarine, and anti-surface capability. All those PRC Naval Militia ships…a MK-48 is just too much for them, and not enough. A gaggle of MK-58s? Now we’re talking. You can have all the surface-to-air missiles, railguns, lasers, and kitchen sinks in the world to throw at attack drones, ASCM, and ASBM…but what are you going to do with you have an angry cluster of a couple of dozen MK-58s headed your way loaded with the latest AI driven software riding on a modern seeker head? How close will you get to shore when any converted jet ski could carry a couple? Heck, back up a pickup truck to a boat ramp and spit out a half dozen for a little redneck shore battery. How many of these puppies can an XLUUV carry? Encouraging. Very encouraging. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Share Leave a comment View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Episode 23: 09JUL2025
Show LinksCoast Guard Petty Officer Scott Ruskan Modern Chinese Maritime Forces, 01JUL2025 Edition. Frontline states say “bye” to the Ottawa Convention on Mines. King's Navy: Fleet Admiral Ernest J. King and the Rise of American Sea Power, 1897–1947 Heritage DataViz on US Fleet promises v. PLAN Execution MK-58 torpedo SummaryIn this episode, the host discusse… Read more View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Wait...We Don't Have to Give up on the Railgun?
Oh, my love and forlorn desire has appeared before me once again to cause me to hope and to think of what might have been. Alas, as with many things you crave too much but never capture, over the years you feel cheated, heartbroken, and perhaps a little bitter…but still, you long for the promise always right out of reach. The railgun. Directly, I first wrote about it on the OG Blog almost fifteen years ago, and indirectly over fifteen years ago. Let’s visit when I addressed it directly: With the advances of technology, computers, and a better understanding of what it takes to destroy a missile in flight - in 15 years and utility and effectiveness of the missile as an offensive weapon might come under significant risk. When you think about it - a missile is a very fragile thing. A gun round designed to go from 0 to Mach 7 in just a few meters? That is a little tougher to kill. From Gun to Missile to Gun. A new era for a primary weapon perhaps? The gun never left us of course ... but could she regain her top billing? Keep the transformationalists away from the program - don't over sell it - and follow the best practices of the 1950-60s missile programs in rolling out the new weapon. If we do that, I think we might have something here. The fundamentals of war at sea and projection of power ashore will remain the same - just how you do it will change. With the advances of technology, computers, and a better understanding of what it takes to destroy a missile in flight - in 15 years and utility and effectiveness of the missile as an offensive weapon might come under significant risk. When you think about it - a missile is a very fragile thing. A gun round designed to go from 0 to Mach 7 in just a few meters? That is a little tougher to kill. From Gun to Missile to Gun. A new era for a primary weapon perhaps? The gun never left us of course ... but could she regain her top billing? Keep the transformationalists away from the program - don't over sell it - and follow the best practices of the 1950-60s missile programs in rolling out the new weapon. If we do that, I think we might have something here. The fundamentals of war at sea and projection of power ashore will remain the same - just how you do it will change. I have been writing for so long that the “distant future” is, well, now. When I wrote the above in 2010, I referenced progress in 15 years, the same length of time from today to 2040. Well, at least I got the vulnerability of missiles correct. Just look at the performance of the US Navy and Army, along with their Israeli counterparts, against Iranian ballistic missiles over the last few years at sea and ashore. However…the railgun remains just a mirage. Though we punted, we know the Chinese are giving it a shot. Can the Japanese make it happen? Well, let’s check in with Joseph Trevithick at TWZ: New pictures have emerged showing work being done on the Japan Self-Defense Forces’ prototype electromagnetic railgun currently installed on the test warship JS Asuka. An at-sea test of the weapon in this configuration is expected to come before the end of the month, if it has not occurred already. Japan’s continued developments in this realm stand in notable contrast to the U.S. Navy’s shelving of its promising pursuit of this category of weapons in the early 2020s after major technical hurdles emerged. The images of Asuka and its railgun in port in Yokosuka, seen at the top of this story and below, come from @HNlEHupY4Nr6hRM on X who originally posted online. All of the images were taken on June 30. Additional photos of the ship taken recently are also circulating online. Asuka, a 6,200-ton-displacement dedicated testbed with a warship-like design, first emerged with the turreted railgun on its stern flight deck in April. Crawl, walk, run? In past testing, ATLA has reportedly demonstrated the ability to fire rounds at a velocity of around 4,988 miles per hour (2,230 meters per second; Mach 6.5) while using five megajoules (MJ), or 5 million joules (J), of charge energy. As of April, prior testing goals had included a muzzle velocity of at least 4,473 miles-per-hour (2,000 meters-per-second) and a barrel life of 120 rounds, according to Naval News. Reports say that ATLA has also been working to reduce the weapon’s power requirements. Build a little. Test a little. Learn a lot. In May, Aviation Week reported that at least one at-sea test of Asuka‘s railgun installation was set to occur sometime in June. Yahoo Japan subsequently published a story saying that the testing window would span from June 9 to July 25. That same piece said that the test ship had been observed departing Yokosuka on June 9, but it is unclear whether or not any live-fire testing has yet taken place. Speaking through an interpreter at a panel discussion at DSEI Japan 2025, Kazumi Ito, principal director of the equipment policy division at ATLA, said Japan’s railgun efforts were “progressing,” but acknowledged “various challenges,” according to National Defense Magazine. I’ve looked around but haven’t seen anything yet. If you have, put it in comments. I like Christian Orr’s thinking here four days ago: Digging further, we learn from an article by James Keller of Task & Purpose that the USN’s railgun program was officially declared dead in July 2021 “in light of ‘fiscal constraints, combat system integration challenges and the prospective technology maturation of other weapon concepts,’ according to a statement provided to Military.com.” The US Navy’s researchers spent 15 years and $500 million on research and testing. Yet, they were unable to solve the vexing problems that their Japanese counterparts had solved in less than half the time and with just over 1 percent of the amount of money spent. Perhaps the USN will be able to apply lessons learned from their Japanese counterparts and pool resources to develop railguns as a joint venture going forward. Another technical challenge of railgun technology that has yet to be overcome is that they require an enormous power supply—to the tune of a million or so amperes of current—making the portability of railguns a daunting prospect. OK, we can add this to the list with the ShinMaywa US-2. The Japanese buy a lot of our national security kit. In addition to buying a couple-three dozen US-2, if the Japanese engineers have cracked a code, let them lead but with whatever money and intellectual help they need to make it better faster—and then buy it from them. Will I be posting about railguns, the “weapon of tomorrow, and always will be” like this in 2040, 15 more years in the future, still heartbroken? We’ll see—Lord willing and the Creek don’t rise. Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - How to Blunt a PRC Invasion of Taiwan? Operation Swooper
Fourteen years since the announced “Pacific Pivot”, the last month we’ve been subjected to a very public debate about how much support for Ukraine in her war with Russia is impacting our ability to prepare for potential war with China in the Pacific. Though history prefers to throw a curveball more often than not, the one scenario that is seen as the most likely trigger for the next Great Pacific War is Taiwan. Should this war come—and if we prepare properly for it, it very well may not—are we ready to make any attempt to take Taiwan a debacle for People’s Republic of China (PRC) a debacle, or are we under-preparing to the degree that we will slouch our way into a long drawn-out war? One thing I am sure of, we continue to overlook a key capability not from lack of imagination but from lack of sponsorship to get it through from a small, niche capability to a massive hammer against the enemy at sea. Nothing needs to be “invented” with unobtainium. It isn’t exquisitely priced. It isn’t reliant on a Tiffany-fragile CONOPS. It has already been developed. It already is at full operational capability. It is already proven at war. It is right there, neglected, underfunded, and unloved. Mining. I’m talking about mining. One of the most important, deadly, and impactful weapons at sea—but probably one of the ones least respected. Offensive mining, defensive mining—so much has been lost, forgotten, or just thrown away in this warfare area, that it is almost a crime itself. Mortgaged, sold away, or just plain neglected in pursuit of vanity projects and theories that never leave the PowerPoint. Some capabilities are so impressive and have such a long track record of success, you wonder why it doesn’t get more attention and funding. It can make you wonder, “Am I the one missing something?” Then you realize that this capability you believe is so important is, unfortunately, unsexy. Yes, you remind yourself, even in national defense, you never really leave the middle school lunchroom. Nothing will terrify the crew of a ship faster than hearing, “MINES”! As Tom Wester and Joe Mancini over at WOTR reminded us two years ago, Of the 19 U.S. ships sunk or severely damaged since 1945, 15 were victims of mines, and yet mine warfare is carelessly neglected while U.S. allies, partners, and adversaries continue to expand their programs’ capability and capacity. During the initial weeks of Russia’s invasion, Ukraine hardened its defenses by laying mines in littoral waters. While the mines helped prevent Russia from mounting an amphibious assault, If you want to halt a surface force’s momentum, lay mines. You want to cause an operation to be delayed or cancelled altogether, lay mines they don’t know are there. You want to deny access to certain waters, mine them. Don’t let the enemy assume access to anything you can reach. Destroy their carefully crafted CONOPS. Shatter their timeline. Deny their assumptions. As they move to take what they covet—be the swooper. LTjg Salamander’s view of the impact—pun intended—of mines date back to the HF TTY message traffic that came in about the USS Tripoli (LPH 10) and USS Princeton (CG 59) striking Iraqi mines in Desert Storm 1991, just three years after USS Samuel B. Roberts (FFG-58) was hit by an Iranian one. The first few days of any conflict over Taiwan will be critical. The PRC will want its action to absorb Taiwan to be quick, decisive, and as bloodless as possible. They want the facts on the ground to be resolved before the American fleet sails west of the International Date Line. It is clear that the PRC is trying to build and amphibious capability to bring the number and type of forces ashore that it will need to quickly pacify Taiwan with as little damage as possible. She is worth much more intact than as rubble and ashes. Amphibious landings have a certain logic to them. They need to gain, keep, and expand momentum. From Gallipoli to Normandy, that transition point of moving inland must take place or the landing will fail. One of the best ways for the landing to fail is for the defender to interrupt additional supplies, men, and material from coming ashore. If you can prevent that, even the most violently successful invasion at D+0 will fail by D+14. What is one tool that could blunt a successful invasion of Taiwan that some people in the Pentagon know we need, but don’t seem to be able to get the funding to move it to a critical mass? It’s mining, of course, but for this scenario our war-hack is a special subset of mining: aerial mining. In the relatively narrow waters of the Taiwan Strait, surface mine laying is a suicide mission. Submarine-delivered mines can only be delivered by the remaining Los Angeles Class submarines, and you don’t want them prowling in those shallow waters. “Other” options will not be ready in time…if ever. Long range and even carrier aircraft can deliver in hours or days what other mining assets would take weeks to months to deliver. They don’t need bases on hostile land; they just need to get there. But wait, if you want to lay even defensive minefields in the Taiwan Strait, you want to keep your aircraft—an F/A-18, P-8, B-1, or B-52, as far east as possible. Right? That is deadly airspace. Well, there’s an answer to that. Quickstrike ER (QS-ER). The QS-ER concept marries an Mk64 underwater mine to the Joint Direct Attack Munition (JDAM) Extended Range variant to strike a target precisely from a stand-off range of over 40 miles (64 kilometers). The JDAM kit comprises a GPS-assisted inertial navigation guidance system that aids a munition in gliding toward the designated target. The concept allows an aircraft to deliver multiple 2,000-pound (907 kilograms) guided air-launched mines simultaneously in a contested waterway with lower risk. In comparison, an unguided mine requires launching at multiple intervals, with the aircraft flying at dangerously low altitudes. “What’s unique about QS-ER is its range and precision,” 49th Test and Evaluation Squadron commander Lt. Col. Matt Spinelli said. OK. 40 nautical miles. Just for planning purposes, what if aircraft were restricted to releasing weapons overland Taiwan? How far could they lay a minefield? What does that look like between Taiwan and the PRC? There’s your 40 nautical miles a QS-ER can glide. Flying from east to west and back “home” wherever that base is. Unlikely the PRC will have air supremacy over Taiwan proper. That red line is 344 nautical miles long. Depth 500: feet at the end of the lines (that leads to deep water where thar be SSN dragons), but the majority water depth is 100-200’ for most of the Taiwan Strait—a fertile field for sowing mines. From what I have been able to find in open source, a B-52 can carry 12 QS-ER. A B-1 24, and a B-2 16. B-2 will have a “higher and best use” in a Great Pacific War, so that leaves the B-1 and B-52 from the USAF. A lot will depend on range requirements, but I believe the F/A-18 Super Hornet can carry two and the P-8A can carry five 2,000-class weapons like the QS-ER. Navy can help out, but the USAF will need to be the primary player for any significant mining campaign in defense of Taiwan. You don’t have to mine it all, just the most likely approaches to where the PRC wants to be, or are most suitable for their special-purpose landing barges. The PRC can have uncomfortable uncertainty on where the rest of the mines are. Fear is the defender’s ally. Mines buy time, narrow access. That is what you need to make any invasion, should it take place, have a better likelihood to fail at best, give Taiwan and her allies the time they need to reinforce her at worst. I know, mining is unsexy, but it is important. Even amongst professionals, it is hard to keep track of If you would like a bit more about the US Navy’s unclassified mining assets, here’s a nice summary in the below video. Just in the last century, let’s look at two good benchmarks of the power of American mining. The Institute for Defense Analysis’s 1997, The 1972 Mining of Haiphong Harbor: A Case Study in Naval Mining and Diplomacy - AKA Operation Pocket Money: The Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Admiral Thomas Moorer, had long argued for strategic mining of the major ports in North Vietnam. As Commander, U.S. Pacific Fleet and as Chief of Naval Operations, he had presented plans and arguments for mining major North Vietnamese ports. His views had repeatedly been ignored or rejected. As the new CJCS, his views were finally accepted in 1972. About 80 percent of the supplies to North Vietnam came in via the sea ports in the Haiphong harbors. All oil came into Hanoi through the harbors. … Many mines had been dropped during the entire war, approximately 330.000.18 (Over 11,000 were eventually laid in Haiphong harbors.) But the mining of the strategic harbors had until May 1972 been considered too risky and disproportionate.19 One can only speculate about what might have happened if mining on this scale had been executed earlier in the conflict, as had been argued by Admiral Moorer. … The first mines were laid by tactical air from the naval aircraft carrier USS Coral Sea. Immediately, all shipping stopped at Haiphong, even though the mines were not armed until 3 days later. In accordance with international law, a warning to mariners was made, with sufficient lead-time for shipping to clear the area before the minefield became active. No ships entered Haiphong and those there at the beginning of the mining did not leave and were trapped, so dangerous the mine field was perceived to be. Trucks and trains moved along the overland routes that were under attack, but no ships challenged the mine field. The psychological impact of the minefield was clear, even if disproportionate to the actual threat. A major sea supply route to North Vietnam had been severed. … As a result of the lengthy delay, the minefields had to be reseeded several times, since the mines were set to sterilize themselves in less than 6 months.27 Also, a serious electromagnetic anomaly from a sunspot detonated a large number of mines. They also were replaced. As noted earlier, over 11,000 mines were eventually laid near Haiphong. I have a pretty solid idea why Admiral Moorer was such an advocate of mining. As a naval aviator in WWII, Admiral Moorer would have been very familiar with one of the most accurately named operations of the war: Operation Starvation: More than 1,250,000 tons of shipping was sunk or damaged in the last five months of World War II when Twenty-first Bomber Command executed an aerial mining campaign against Japan known as Operation STARVATION. Despite this outstanding success, the decision to commit the still unproven B-29 to minelaying was a close one that rose to the highest levels of the Services. The decision to conduct Operation STARVATION was made not only because mining would lead to a Japanese surrender without the need for a costly invasion of the home islands, but also with an eye towards post-war roles and missions for the Air Force. Once the decision was taken, General Curtis LeMay and his Twenty-first Bomber Command threw themselves wholeheartedly into the mission. On January 23, 1945, LeMay issued a general directive to the 313th Bombardment Wing to prepare for minelaying operations and on March 27, the 313th flew the first of over 50 mining missions. Working together on the remote island of Tinian, Air Force and Navy personnel turned a mission that began as an inter-service rivalry into one of the best examples of inter-service cooperation of the Pacific War. From the same 2002 USAF’s Air War College paper by Gerald A. Mason, Captain, USN linked to above, we need to think carefully about our investment in aerial mining. Do we have enough for peacetime training and exercises, or are we buying enough to make to leverage this capability at D+1? During Operation STARVATION, more than 1,250,000 tons of shipping was sunk or damaged during the last five months of the war. Approximately 12,000 mines were laid requiring only 5.7 percent of the Twenty-first Bomber Command’s total effort. Out of 1,529 B29 mining sorties, only 15 aircraft failed to return. In the five months prior to the end of hostilities, mines sank or damaged more shipping than any other agent including submarines or direct air attack by both Army and Naval forces. The Shimonoseki Straits and allimportant industrial ports were almost completely blockaded. Hundreds of ships were delayed, sunk, or damaged and supplies vitally needed in industrial and populated sections were diverted to northern Honshu ports where much of it remained, waiting to be hauled over an already overloaded transportation system to its useful destination. Now, look back at the summary of the mines we laid in Operations Pocket Money and Starvation. What is our inventory of Quickstrike ER kits? A strong asset is right there, waiting for us to take advantage of it. Right there. No development cost, just production and storage. Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Happy July 4th
CALVIN COOLIDGE30th President of the United States: 1923 ‐ 1929 July 05, 1926 Fellow Countrymen: We meet to celebrate the birthday of America. The coming of a new life always excites our interest. Although we know in the case of the individual that it has been an infinite repetition reaching back beyond our vision, that only makes it more wonderful. But how our interest and wonder increase when we behold the miracle of the birth of a new nation. It is to pay our tribute of reverence and respect to those who participated in such a mighty event that we annually observe the 4th day of July. Whatever may have been the impression created by the news which went out from this city on that summer day in 1776, there can be no doubt as to the estimate which is now placed upon it. At the end of 150 years the four corners of the earth unite in coming to Philadelphia as to a holy shrine in grateful acknowledgment of a service so great, which a few inspired men here rendered to humanity, that it is still the preeminent support of free government throughout the world. Although a century and a half measured in comparison with the length of human experience is but a short time, yet measured in the life of governments and nations it ranks as a very respectable period. Certainly enough time has elapsed to demonstrate with a great deal of thoroughness the value of our institutions and their dependability as rules for the regulation of human conduct and the advancement of civilization. They have been in existence long enough to become very well seasoned. They have met, and met successfully, the test of experience It is not so much, then, for the purpose of undertaking to proclaim new theories and principles that this annual celebration is maintained, but rather to reaffirm and reestablish those old theories and principles which time and the unerring logic of events have demonstrated to be sound. Amid all the clash of conflicting interests, amid all the welter of partisan politics, every American can turn for solace and consolation to the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of the United States with the assurance and confidence that those two great charters of freedom and justice remain firm and unshaken. Whatever perils appear, whatever dangers threaten, the Nation remains secure in the knowledge that the ultimate application of the law of the land will provide an adequate defense and protection. It is little wonder that people at home and abroad consider Independence Hall as hallowed ground and revere the Liberty Bell as a sacred relic. That pile of bricks and mortar, that mass of metal, might appear to the uninstructed as only the outgrown meeting place and the shattered bell of a former time, useless now because of more modern conveniences, but to those who know they have become consecrated by the use which men have made of them. They have long been identified with a great cause. They are the framework of a spiritual event. The world looks upon them, because of their associations of one hundred and fifty years ago, as it looks upon the Holy Land because of what took place there nineteen hundred years ago. Through use for a righteous purpose they have become sanctified. It is not here necessary to examine in detail the causes which led to the American Revolution. In their immediate occasion they were largely economic. The colonists objected to the navigation laws which interfered with their trade, they denied the power of Parliament to impose taxes which they were obliged to pay, and they therefore resisted the royal governors and the royal forces which were sent to secure obedience to these laws. But the conviction is inescapable that a new civilization had come, a new spirit had arisen on this side of the Atlantic more advanced and more developed in its regard for the rights of the individual than that which characterized the Old World. Life in a new and open country had aspirations which could not be realized in any subordinate position. A separate establishment was ultimately inevitable. It had been decreed by the very laws of human nature. Man everywhere has an unconquerable desire to be the master of his own destiny. We are obliged to conclude that the Declaration of Independence represented the movement of a people. It was not, of course, a movement from the top. Revolutions do not come from that direction. It was not without the support of many of the most respectable people in the Colonies, who were entitled to all the consideration that is given to breeding, education, and possessions. It had the support of another element of great significance and importance to which I shall later refer. But the preponderance of all those who occupied a position which took on the aspect of aristocracy did not approve of the Revolution and held toward it an attitude either of neutrality or open hostility. It was in no sense a rising of the oppressed and downtrodden. It brought no scum to the surface, for the reason that colonial society had developed no scum. The great body of the people were accustomed to privations, but they were free from depravity. If they had poverty, it was not of the hopeless kind that afflicts great cities, but the inspiring kind that marks the spirit of the pioneer. The American Revolution represented the informed and mature convictions of a great mass of independent, liberty loving, God-fearing people who knew their rights, and possessed the courage to dare to maintain them. The Continental Congress was not only composed of great men, but it represented a great people. While its Members did not fail to exercise a remarkable leadership, they were equally observant of their representative capacity. They were industrious in encouraging their constituents to instruct them to support independence. But until such instructions were given they were inclined to withhold action. While North Carolina has the honor of first authorizing its delegates to concur with other Colonies in declaring independence, it was quickly followed by South Carolina and Georgia, which also gave general instructions broad enough to include such action. But the first instructions which unconditionally directed its delegates to declare for independence came from the great Commonwealth of Virginia. These were immediately followed by Rhode Island and Massachusetts, while the other Colonies, with the exception of New York, soon adopted a like course. This obedience of the delegates to the wishes of their constituents, which in some cases caused them to modify their previous positions, is a matter of great significance. It reveals an orderly process of government in the first place; but more than that, it demonstrates that the Declaration of Independence was the result of the seasoned and deliberate thought of the dominant portion of the people of the Colonies. Adopted after long discussion and as the result of the duly authorized expression of the preponderance of public opinion, it did not partake of dark intrigue or hidden conspiracy. It was well advised. It had about it nothing of the lawless and disordered nature of a riotous insurrection. It was maintained on a plane which rises above the ordinary conception of rebellion. It was in no sense a radical movement but took on the dignity of a resistance to illegal usurpations. It was conservative and represented the action of the colonists to maintain their constitutional rights which from time immemorial had been guaranteed to them under the law of the land. When we come to examine the action of the Continental Congress in adopting the Declaration of Independence in the light of what was set out in that great document and in the light of succeeding events, we can not escape the conclusion that it had a much broader and deeper significance than a mere secession of territory and the establishment of a new nation. Events of that nature have been taking place since the dawn of history. One empire after another has arisen, only to crumble away as its constituent parts separated from each other and set up independent governments of their own. Such actions long ago became commonplace. They have occurred too often to hold the attention of the world and command the administration and reverence of humanity. There is something beyond the establishment of a new nation, great as that event would be, in the Declaration of Independence which has ever since caused it to be regarded as one of the great charters that not only was to liberate America but was everywhere to ennoble humanity. It was not because it was proposed to establish a new nation, but because it was proposed to establish a nation on new principles, that July 4, 1776, has come to be regarded as one of the greatest days in history. Great ideas do not burst upon the world unannounced. They are reached by a gradual development over a length of time usually proportionate to their importance. This is especially true of the principles laid down in the Declaration of Independence. Three very definite propositions were set out in its preamble regarding the nature of mankind and therefore of government. These were the doctrine that all men are created equal, that they are endowed with certain inalienable rights, and that therefore the source of the just powers of government must be derived from the consent of the governed. If no one is to be accounted as born into a superior station, if there is to be no ruling class, and if all possess rights which can neither be bartered away nor taken from them by any earthly power, it follows as a matter of course that the practical authority of the Government has to rest on the consent of the governed. While these principles were not altogether new in political action, and were very far from new in political speculation, they had never been assembled before and declared in such a combination. But remarkable as this may be, it is not the chief distinction of the Declaration of Independence. The importance of political speculation is not to be underestimated, as I shall presently disclose. Until the idea is developed and the plan made there can be no action. It was the fact that our Declaration of Independence containing these immortal truths was the political action of a duly authorized and constituted representative public body in its sovereign capacity, supported by the force of general opinion and by the armies of Washington already in the field, which makes it the most important civil document in the world. It was not only the principles declared, but the fact that therewith a new nation was born which was to be founded upon those principles and which from that time forth in its development has actually maintained those principles, that makes this pronouncement an incomparable event in the history of government. It was an assertion that a people had arisen determined to make every necessary sacrifice for the support of these truths and by their practical application bring the War of Independence to a successful conclusion and adopt the Constitution of the United States with all that it has meant to civilization. The idea that the people have a right to choose their own rulers was not new in political history. It was the foundation of every popular attempt to depose an undesirable king. This right was set out with a good deal of detail by the Dutch when as early as July 26, 1581, they declared their independence of Philip of Spain. In their long struggle with the Stuarts the British people asserted the same principles, which finally culminated in the Bill of Rights deposing the last of that house and placing William and Mary on the throne. In each of these cases sovereignty through divine right was displaced by sovereignty through the consent of the people. Running through the same documents, though expressed in different terms, is the clear inference of inalienable rights. But we should search these charters in vain for an assertion of the doctrine of equality. This principle had not before appeared as an official political declaration of any nation. It was profoundly revolutionary. It is one of the corner stones of American institutions. But if these truths to which the Declaration refers have not before been adopted in their combined entirely by national authority, it is a fact that they had been long pondered and often expressed in political speculation. It is generally assumed that French thought had some effect upon our public mind during Revolutionary days. This may have been true. But the principles of our Declaration had been under discussion in the Colonies for nearly two generations before the advent of the French political philosophy that characterized the middle of the eighteenth century. In fact, they come from an earlier date. A very positive echo of what the Dutch had done in 1581, and what the English were preparing to do, appears in the assertion of the Rev. Thomas Hooker, of Connecticut, as early as 1638, when he said in a sermon before the General Court that-- The foundation of authority is laid in the free consent of the people. The choice of public magistrates belongs to the people by God's own allowance. This doctrine found wide acceptance among the nonconformist clergy who later made up the Congregational Church. The great apostle of this movement was the Rev. John Wise, of Massachusetts. He was one of the leaders of the revolt against the royal governor Andros in 1687, for which he suffered imprisonment. He was a liberal in ecclesiastical controversies. He appears to have been familiar with the writings of the political scientist, Samuel Pufendorf, who was born in Saxony in 1632. Wise published a treatise entitled "The Church's Quarrel Espoused" in 1710, which was amplified in another publication in 1717. In it he dealt with the principles of civil government. His works were reprinted in 1772 and have been declared to have been nothing less than a textbook of liberty for our Revolutionary fathers. While the written word was the foundation, it is apparent that the spoken word was the vehicle for convincing the people. This came with great force and wide range from the successors of Hooker and Wise. It was carried on with a missionary spirit which did not fail to reach the Scotch-Irish of North Carolina, showing its influence by significantly making that Colony the first to give instructions to its delegates looking to independence. This preaching reached the neighborhood of Thomas Jefferson, who acknowledged that his "best ideas of democracy" had been secured at church meetings. That these ideas were prevalent in Virginia is further revealed by the Declaration of Rights, which was prepared by George Mason and presented to the general assembly on May 27, 1776. This document asserted popular sovereignty and inherent natural rights, but confined the doctrine of equality to the assertion that "All men are created equally free and independent." It can scarcely be imagined that Jefferson was unacquainted with what had been done in his own Commonwealth of Virginia when he took up the task of drafting the Declaration of Independence. But these thoughts can very largely be traced back to what John Wise was writing in 1710. He said, "Every man must be acknowledged equal to every man." Again, "The end of all good government is to cultivate humanity and promote the happiness of all and the good of every man in all his rights, his life, liberty, estate, honor, and so forth * * *." And again, "For as they have a power every man in his natural state, so upon combination they can and do bequeath this power to others and settle it according as their united discretion shall determine." And still again, "Democracy is Christ's government in church and state." Here was the doctrine of equality, popular sovereignty, and the substance of the theory of inalienable rights clearly asserted by Wise at the opening of the eighteenth century, just as we have the principle of the consent of the governed state by Hooker as early as 1638. When we take all these circumstances into consideration, it is but natural that the first paragraph of the Declaration of Independence should open with a reference to Nature's God and should close in the final paragraphs with an appeal to the Supreme Judge of the world and an assertion of a firm reliance on Divine Providence. Coming from these sources, having as it did this background, it is no wonder that Samuel Adams could say "The people seem to recognize this resolution as though it were a decree promulgated from heaven." No one can examine this record and escape the conclusion that in the great outline of its principles the Declaration was the result of the religious teachings of the preceding period. The profound philosophy which Jonathan Edwards applied to theology, the popular preaching of George Whitefield, had aroused the thought and stirred the people of the Colonies in preparation for this great event. No doubt the speculations which had been going on in England, and especially on the Continent, lent their influence to the general sentiment of the times. Of course, the world is always influenced by all the experience and all the thought of the past. But when we come to a contemplation of the immediate conception of the principles of human relationship which went into the Declaration of Independence we are not required to extend our search beyond our own shores. They are found in the texts, the sermons, and the writings of the early colonial clergy who were earnestly undertaking to instruct their congregations in the great mystery of how to live. They preached equality because they believed in the fatherhood of God and the brotherhood of man. They justified freedom by the text that we are all created in the divine image, all partakers of the divine spirit. Placing every man on a plane where he acknowledged no superiors, where no one possessed any right to rule over him, he must inevitably choose his own rulers through a system of self-government. This was their theory of democracy. In those days such doctrines would scarcely have been permitted to flourish and spread in any other country. This was the purpose which the fathers cherished. In order that they might have freedom to express these thoughts and opportunity to put them into action, whole congregations with their pastors had migrated to the Colonies. These great truths were in the air that our people breathed. Whatever else we may say of it, the Declaration of Independence was profoundly American. If this apprehension of the facts be correct, and the documentary evidence would appear to verify it, then certain conclusions are bound to follow. A spring will cease to flow if its source be dried up; a tree will wither if it roots be destroyed. In its main features the Declaration of Independence is a great spiritual document. It is a declaration not of material but of spiritual conceptions. Equality, liberty, popular sovereignty, the rights of man - these are not elements which we can see and touch. They are ideals. They have their source and their roots in the religious convictions. They belong to the unseen world. Unless the faith of the American people in these religious convictions is to endure, the principles of our Declaration will perish. We can not continue to enjoy the result if we neglect and abandon the cause. We are too prone to overlook another conclusion. Governments do not make ideals, but ideals make governments. This is both historically and logically true. Of course the government can help to sustain ideals and can create institutions through which they can be the better observed, but their source by their very nature is in the people. The people have to bear their own responsibilities. There is no method by which that burden can be shifted to the government. It is not the enactment, but the observance of laws, that creates the character of a nation. About the Declaration there is a finality that is exceedingly restful. It is often asserted that the world has made a great deal of progress since 1776, that we have had new thoughts and new experiences which have given us a great advance over the people of that day, and that we may therefore very well discard their conclusions for something more modern. But that reasoning can not be applied to this great charter. If all men are created equal, that is final. If they are endowed with inalienable rights, that is final. If governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed, that is final. No advance, no progress can be made beyond these propositions. If anyone wishes to deny their truth or their soundness, the only direction in which he can proceed historically is not forward, but backward toward the time when there was no equality, no rights of the individual, no rule of the people. Those who wish to proceed in that direction can not lay claim to progress. They are reactionary. Their ideas are not more modern, but more ancient, than those of the Revolutionary fathers. In the development of its institutions America can fairly claim that it has remained true to the principles which were declared 150 years ago. In all the essentials we have achieved an equality which was never possessed by any other people. Even in the less important matter of material possessions we have secured a wider and wider distribution of wealth. The rights of the individual are held sacred and protected by constitutional guaranties which even the Government itself is bound not to violate. If there is any one thing among us that is established beyond question, it is self-government - the right of the people to rule. If there is any failure in respect to any of these principles, it is because there is a failure on the part of individuals to observe them. We hold that the duly authorized expression of the will of the people has a divine sanction. But even in that we come back to the theory of John Wise that "Democracy is Christ's government * * *." The ultimate sanction of law rests on the righteous authority of the Almighty. On an occasion like this great temptation exists to present evidence of the practical success of our form of democratic republic at home and the ever-broadening acceptance it is securing abroad. Although these things are well known, their frequent consideration is an encouragement and an inspiration. But it is not results and effects so much as sources and causes that I believe it is even more necessary constantly to contemplate. Ours is a government of the people. It represents their will. Its officers may sometimes go astray, but that is not a reason for criticizing the principles of our institutions. The real heart of the American Government depends upon the heart of the people. It is from that source that we must look for all genuine reform. It is to that cause that we must ascribe all our results. It was in the contemplation of these truths that the fathers made their declaration and adopted their Constitution. It was to establish a free government, which must not be permitted to degenerate into the unrestrained authority of a mere majority or the unbridled weight of a mere influential few. They undertook to balance these interests against each other and provide the three separate independent branches, the executive, the legislative, and the judicial departments of the Government, with checks against each other in order that neither one might encroach upon the other. These are our guarantees of liberty. As a result of these methods enterprise has been duly protected from confiscation, the people have been free from oppression, and there has been an ever-broadening and deepening of the humanities of life. Under a system of popular government there will always be those who will seek for political preferment by clamoring for reform. While there is very little of this which is not sincere, there is a large portion that is not well informed. In my opinion very little of just criticism can attach to the theories and principles of our institutions. There is far more danger of harm than there is hope of good in any radical changes. We do need a better understanding and comprehension of them and a better knowledge of the foundations of government in general. Our forefathers came to certain conclusions and decided upon certain courses of action which have been a great blessing to the world. Before we can understand their conclusions we must go back and review the course which they followed. We must think the thoughts which they thought. Their intellectual life centered around the meetinghouse. They were intent upon religious worship. While there were always among them men of deep learning, and later those who had comparatively large possessions, the mind of the people was not so much engrossed in how much they knew, or how much they had, as in how they were going to live. While scantily provided with other literature, there was a wide acquaintance with the Scriptures. Over a period as great as that which measures the existence of our independence they were subject to this discipline not only in their religious life and educational training, but also in their political thought. They were a people who came under the influence of a great spiritual development and acquired a great moral power. No other theory is adequate to explain or comprehend the Declaration of Independence. It is the product of the spiritual insight of the people. We live in an age of science and of abounding accumulation of material things. These did not create our Declaration. Our Declaration created them. The things of the spirit come first. Unless we cling to that, all our material prosperity, overwhelming though it may appear, will turn to a barren scepter in our grasp. If we are to maintain the great heritage which has been bequeathed to us, we must be like-minded as the fathers who created it. We must not sink into a pagan materialism. We must cultivate the reverence which they had for the things that are holy. We must follow the spiritual and moral leadership which they showed. We must keep replenished, that they may glow with a more compelling flame, the altar fires before which they worshiped. Leave a comment Share Subscribe now View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - Shipbuilding: Patience or Dispair?
I am sure that most navalists have had a moment or two in the last few months where they’ve wanted to shuffle down to the basement to get their ready sackcloth and ashes and roll in the doom. The news can lead you that way. Let’s check in with Paul Berger at WSJ; In the first major speech to Congress of his second term, President Trump vowed to resurrect American shipbuilding. Four months later, Trump’s ambitious plans to reverse decades of maritime-industry decline are sputtering. Are they? Maybe sputtering or trying to find their footing in the chaos. It’s the first few months of an administration dealing with a low-boil naval conflict in the Red Sea, year two of the war between Iranian proxies (and, no kidding, Iran) and Israel, year four of the Russo-Ukrainian War, a nervous NATO, an expanding China, and whatever’s up with Taylor Swift. Oh, and Trump has only been in office for six months, and it has been only 120 days since the March speech. 120 days. Sen. Roger Wicker (R., Miss.), chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, said during a June 10 hearing that he was disappointed with the administration’s budget request for the Navy for the next fiscal year, in particular a reduction in the shipbuilding budget to less than $21 billion from $37 billion the prior year. Wicker said the request reflected efforts to “game the budget” in anticipation of extra money being made available from so-called reconciliation funds that Congress can approve outside the broader budget process. He also said he was alarmed the request didn’t include the usual procurement of destroyers. “Failing to include two destroyers in this year’s budget request destabilizes industry, shows bad faith and slows our shipbuilding efforts,” he said. Trump’s top budget official, Russ Vought, has denied cuts are being made to shipbuilding. Vought, the director of the White House Office of Management and Budget, in a post on X following the hearing said the total shipbuilding request for the coming year is $47.4 billion, about 21% above the prior year’s budget. “We simply use both discretionary and mandatory spending on the One Big Beautiful bill to do it,” Vought said. OMB officials note that two destroyers are included in the tax-and-spending bill that passed the Senate on Tuesday and that has been sent back to the House for final touches. … The senior administration official said: “The right-sizing of the NSC has made processes more streamlined and efficient.” Robert Obayda, founder of market research firm Rivertes Group and a former official in the office who co-wrote the shipbuilding executive order, said: “If you remove them from the equation or reduce their size to two people, I just don’t see how you accomplish that [maritime] goal.” Brent Sadler, a maritime specialist at the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, said he believes the shipbuilding office has enough people to execute the administration’s agenda. He said he is more concerned that the White House hasn’t yet managed to confirm a Maritime Administration chief or name a nominee to oversee Navy shipbuilding. The Trump administration has put forward former Maersk Line executive Stephen Carmel to lead the Maritime Administration, which oversees U.S. maritime programs, including the Merchant Marine. A nomination for the assistant secretary of the Navy for Research, Development and Acquisition, which coordinates Navy shipbuilding, has yet to be made. Sadler, a one-time Trump nominee to run the Maritime Administration, said the two roles are essential to putting maritime executive orders into action. If the administration doesn’t put those officials in place soon, Sadler said: “There’s a probability things are going to get stalled before they get under way.” The SECNAV has been clear by his travel schedule and words this is where his focus is. He doesn’t even have his full team in place (hello Senate). As I like to say, I’m a closet optimist. It is way too early to call doom, and if we reach that point I’ll let you know. The President has said the right things. We have some of the right people in the House and Senate standing by to fill any gaps they see coming from the incomplete Executive Branch team. Industry cannot turn on a dime, and the “system” is slow to respond to rudder commands. Trust but verify? Absolutely, but for now, put the sackcloth and ashes back in the ready box. As the full Navy team gets in place, there will be plenty to discuss. At the end of the day, we should be better than where we were. The global strategic situation demands it. Leave a comment Share This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. View the full article
-
CDR Salamander - The USAF is Having a Good Year
Coming up on seven months of the second Trump Administration, I think it is time to survey the services’ competition for attention, funding, and prioritization. Navalists need to take a deep breath and take a bite of humble pie…and perhaps try to learn something. Of course, I am talking about the U.S. Air Force. The boys (and girls) in blue are having a hell of a year, and it isn’t by accident. Yes, there is timing—but as the Roman philosopher Seneca reminded everyone a couple of thousand years ago: "Luck is what happens when preparation meets opportunity" This is more than just bragging rights. People are drawn to success and performance. So is money, influence, and the power that comes with it. Over the last few years, especially during CNO Gilday’s disastrous tenure, we’ve spent a lot of time discussing the Navy’s missteps. Our Navy squandered institutional capital on foolish initiatives and damaged its reputation with a series of poorly led, managed, and executed programs that failed to produce anything useful that can displace water or cast shadows on the ramp. A decade ago, then candidate Trump went out of his way to promote the idea of our nation needing a strong Navy. Here we are in his second administration, and he continues to voice support…but what has our Navy done in the last decade to prepare for this moment when the executive branch, legislative branch, and the global strategic environment highlights the need for an unchallenged Navy to face the rapidly growing People’s Liberation Army Navy led from Beijing? This should be the moment. This should be our time, and yet were it not for the Cold War-era designed Arleigh Burke-class ships’ serial upgrades and modernizations, we would have no surface fleet. Our carriers cannot meet their full promise because we have taken every step possible this century to decrease its airwing’s size, flexibility, and strike range. We cannot maintain the submarine force we have, and we are not sure how to fix our maintenance—much less expand capacity to fulfill the promise of AUKUS. Our Navy’s inability to get off the mat is not because of our economy, geography, and it sure has little to do with funding. It has everything to do with our bureaucracy, and the system of incentives and disincentives—in place since the fall of the Soviet Union—that have promoted, supported, and failed to hold to account our most senior leaders. I will continue to beat the drum that the U.S. is a maritime and aerospace power. By both geography and national interest, that is where our nation’s comparative advantage is to protect and project our and our allies’ national interest and will across the globe. The moment is now. Clear your mind of all service bias for a moment. You have a few billion dollars to invest in one service or another that seems best ready to blunt any advance by the People’s Republic of China—where do you put it if you agree that the U.S. in the Pacific gets the most bang for its buck in the maritime and aerospace domains? I’m sorry: it is the U.S. Air Force. The Blue Suits are swinging a hot bat. Sure the B-2 and F-22 were designed to defeat the Soviet Union (like the Arleigh Burk DDGs). Sure, they had their production ended WAY TOO EARLY in the Jesus Jones Era, but they are the best technology we have (with a nod to their surviving little brother F-35), and in the strike on Iran they validated the requirement for their replacement. Make no mistake, B-2/F-22 show over Iran sold the future of B-21/F-47; While the US Air Force’s B-2 stealth bomber has become synonymous with the military’s high-stakes air campaign in Iran, other key aerial platforms helped make Operation Midnight Hammer possible and successful. Last week, President Donald Trump revealed that F-35 Lightning IIs and F-22 Raptors also participated in the air campaign targeting Iran’s underground nuclear facilities. While NAVAIR continues to, well, do whatever they are doing since ensuring the light strike fighter Fighter Attack Guys mafia is the last mafia left in TACAIR, the USAF has already stolen a march by getting the green light on the F-47: “F-47, the first crewed sixth-generation fighter, is moving forward with $3.5 billion in funding following President Trump’s March 2025 decision to proceed with Boeing’s development,” a senior U.S. military official said. “The Navy’s FA-XX program will maintain minimal development funding to preserve the ability to leverage F-47 work while preventing over-subscription of qualified defense industrial base engineers.” … “We are maintaining a request of $74 million for the F/A-XX program in this budget to complete the design of that aircraft. We did make a strategic decision to go all in on F-47,” a senior U.S. defense official added. This is “due to our belief that the industrial base can only handle going fast on one program at this time, and the presidential priority to go all in on F-47, and get that program right.” Funding the completion of the design work on the Navy’s program will allow for “maintaining the option for F/A-XX in the future,” the senior U.S. defense official continued. Earlier this month, Boeing Defense and Space CEO Steve Parker very publicly pushed back on the idea that the U.S. industrial base was not capable of working on the F-47 and F/A-XX at the same time. Northrop Grumman has also been in the running for F/A-XX, something the company pressed ahead with after dropping out of the Air Force’s NGAD combat jet competition in 2023. Lockheed Martin was reportedly eliminated from the Navy’s next-generation fighter competition in March. Regardless, the F/A-XX program has been very clearly in limbo for months now. In March, reports indicated that a contract announcement for the Navy’s next-generation fighter would follow quickly from the F-47 news, but that never materialized. A report earlier this month from Bloomberg News, based on budget documents the outlet had seen, said that the Pentagon was instead moving to redirect $500 million in funding from F/A-XX to F-47, and called attention to the industrial base concerns. “At this time, I would say pretty much everything is under consideration to get the TACAIR [tactical aviation] capability that our warfighters need as quickly as possible,” the senior U.S. defense official added in response to a question about whether a navalized variant of the F-47 might now be on the table. “That’s really what we’re looking at the most, is the schedule of all these programs.” All the wrong people are now going to find all the wrong reasons to go after the F/A-XX’s money on one axis, and the mirage of ending manned aircraft from the other. Already there is Lucy tee’n up the football for Charlie Brown to “skip generations” and transform etc—all that snake oil—such that we will have nothing but museum pieces and promises to take west of the International Date Line. In a properly run aviation side of the Navy that could find an ally to push back against Dick Cheney, as we waited for whatever we will call F/A-XX, we would have a follow-on to the F-14D, let’s call a properly managed ASF-14 the F-14E, in addition to a EF-14G. Lots of range and capability—and we could have just had a F/A-18E with no need for the foxtrot. The F-14’s contemporary, the F-15, is having such a renaissance. The USAF refused to let he die, and so we have the “good enough to get the job done now” F-15EX: …F-15EX Eagle II fighter that is being delivered now to the USAF is seeing a significant boost. The program, which has seen drastic fluctuations in planned fleet size, will grow from 98 aircraft to 129. In all, the proposed FY26 budget has $3B set aside for the latest iteration of the iconic 4th generation fighter, according to a senior U.S. Air Force official who answered TWZ‘s question as to the Pentagon’s latest F-15EX’s plans at a press event today. They added that the program of record would become 129 aircraft under the new budget request. The growth in fleet size comes nearly two months after Trump made the surprise announcement that the Michigan Air National Guard, which is losing its A-10 Warthogs, will be reequipped with the F-15EX. As the icing on the cake, the new CJCS is an Air Force 3-star, taken out of retirement, given a 4th star, and so far seems to be doing an exceptional job. There you have it: advantage U.S. Air Force. It isn’t just because, as I mentioned toward the end of last Sunday’s Midrats Podcast, that their blue uniforms are becoming like USMC uniforms—so retro they are cool. No, the USAF has just done a good job being ready for this moment. Not perfect, but better than our Navy. All is not lost for the Navy. We can look at the work the USAF did to be ready for this moment. We have a new team running the Navy and hopefully a confirmed CNO sooner rather than later. Focus on fundamentals. Be skeptical of the people, processes, habits, and institutions that helped put us in the shoal water we are in…and chart a course to better waters. The winds and tides are to our advantage. All we have to do is execute. This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Share Leave a comment View the full article
-
DID - GDIT Maintaining US Army Bases | Israel Says Broken Up Hamas Network in West Bank | Germany Wants Boxer Vehicles
Americas General Dynamics Information Technology (GDIT) has signed a $580-million deal to maintain the security and readiness of US Army bases. This task order encompasses Integrated Base Defense Sustainment Support tasks required to preserve the operational availability of radars, sensors, and cameras that protect installations, their personnel, and infrastructure. A recent Atlantic Council report has sparked debate on how to prepare for simultaneous conflicts with China and North Korea. Based on tabletop exercises known as Guardian Tiger I and II, the report urges a sweeping overhaul of US command arrangements and alliance coordination. Middle East & Africa Israel’s security service said Sunday it had broken up a network of Hamas militants in the occupied West Bank suspected of planning attacks, arresting 60 of the group’s members. The Shin Bet internal security agency said in a statement that “a significant, complex, and large-scale Hamas infrastructure was exposed” in the West Bank city of Hebron. It said it broke up 10 militant cells that “operated to carry out attacks in various formats in the immediate time frame.” Europe Germany has revealed its plan to acquire Boxer armored fighting vehicles to integrate primary capabilities into the military’s newly established Medium Forces. The package includes vehicles in […]View the full article