Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

HarpGamer

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

CDR Salamander - The Pacific Pivot has its Quinceañera

Featured Replies

rssImage-d2af9ee2855258864046e78182504950.jpeg

https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.ama

Earlier this week was the 15th anniversary of President Obama’s “Pacific Pivot” speech in Parliament House in Canberra, Australia on 17 November, 2011. I’ll post a video of the full speech at the bottom of today’s post.

These four paragraphs are the most-quoted portion of the speech. Let’s read it, pick it apart a bit, and then get to the part of the speech I find the most interesting.

So make no mistake, the tide of war is receding, and America is looking ahead to the future that we must build. From Europe to the Americas, we’ve strengthened alliances and partnerships. At home, we’re investing in the sources of our long-term economic strength -- the education of our children, the training of our workers, the infrastructure that fuels commerce, the science and the research that leads to new breakthroughs. We’ve made hard decisions to cut our deficit and put our fiscal house in order -- and we will continue to do more. Because our economic strength at home is the foundation of our leadership in the world, including here in the Asia Pacific.

Our new focus on this region reflects a fundamental truth -- the United States has been, and always will be, a Pacific nation. Asian immigrants helped build America, and millions of American families, including my own, cherish our ties to this region. From the bombing of Darwin to the liberation of Pacific islands, from the rice paddies of Southeast Asia to a cold Korean Peninsula, generations of Americans have served here, and died here -- so democracies could take root; so economic miracles could lift hundreds of millions to prosperity. Americans have bled with you for this progress, and we will not allow it -- we will never allow it to be reversed.

Here, we see the future. As the world’s fastest-growing region -- and home to more than half the global economy -- the Asia Pacific is critical to achieving my highest priority, and that’s creating jobs and opportunity for the American people. With most of the world’s nuclear power and some half of humanity, Asia will largely define whether the century ahead will be marked by conflict or cooperation, needless suffering or human progress.

As President, I have, therefore, made a deliberate and strategic decision -- as a Pacific nation, the United States will play a larger and long-term role in shaping this region and its future, by upholding core principles and in close partnership with our allies and friends.

That first paragraph makes some interesting claims/statements. Let’s see how they stand a decade and a half later. A green comment from me means we’re doing well. Red means, well, notsomuch. Blue, a mixed bag.

Let’s fisk.

  • the tide of war is receding

    • Well, no. Of course he was talking about Afghanistan and Iraq. We know what happened in the years that followed, and from the Pontic Steppe to the Strait of Hormuz. I’m sorry, the tide of war never recedes for long. It ebbs and flows. You only get in trouble if you build your future at the low-water mark.

  • From Europe to the Americas, we’ve strengthened alliances and partnerships.

    • In Europe, we can’t even agree on what to do with the war in Ukraine. None of our NATO allies were interested in mowing the Iranian nuclear grass. However, some of NATO is showing progress (the Baltic Republics and Poland), while the traditional main powers—Great Britain, France, and Germany—are consuming themselves, with too little energy left to think much beyond their borders. Turkey is more Islamist than at any time in a century. Finland and Sweden have joined. On balance, NATO is a mixed bag, but NATO always is. In Asia, things are looking rather solid in the arc from Japan, South Korea, Vietnam, Philippines, and Australia. On balance, not bad. Lots of issues and work to do, but not bad.

  • At home, we’re investing in the sources of our long-term economic strength -- the education of our children, the training of our workers, the infrastructure that fuels commerce, the science and the research that leads to new breakthroughs.

    • We could have done better, but especially in the last few years, a lot of progress has been made. Still, these are only the first steps. However, in the technologies that will define the rest of the century—from AI to compute to aerospace—the U.S.A. is still on top.

  • We’ve made hard decisions to cut our deficit and put our fiscal house in order -- and we will continue to do more. Because our economic strength at home is the foundation of our leadership in the world, including here in the Asia Pacific.

    • Bright, shining red. $40 trillion of unsustainable red.

Next paragraph.

  • Our new focus on this region reflects a fundamental truth -- the United States has been, and always will be, a Pacific nation.

    • More than ever. More people are recognizing this, but not the progress one would expect in 15 years. The big problem is that the gravity of our history and the imperial inertia toward security in Europe and the Middle East will not let us go. Our allies’ sense of entitlement is driving the former, and unending sectarian strife we entangled ourselves in over the decades, the other.

  • Asian immigrants helped build America, and millions of American families, including my own, cherish our ties to this region. From the bombing of Darwin to the liberation of Pacific islands, from the rice paddies of Southeast Asia to a cold Korean Peninsula, generations of Americans have served here, and died here -- so democracies could take root; so economic miracles could lift hundreds of millions to prosperity. Americans have bled with you for this progress, and we will not allow it -- we will never allow it to be reversed.

    • We have allowed the People’s Republic of China (PRC) to expand its influence throughout the small island nations of the Southwest Pacific, into Cambodia, and along the Belt and Road, which now extends into the Western Hemisphere. Until the last couple of years, we largely ignored the problem. Talk is easy on our part. Action is more of a challenge.

  • Here, we see the future. As the world’s fastest-growing region -- and home to more than half the global economy -- the Asia Pacific is critical to achieving my highest priority, and that’s creating jobs and opportunity for the American people. With most of the world’s nuclear power and some half of humanity, Asia will largely define whether the century ahead will be marked by conflict or cooperation, needless suffering or human progress.

    • It will be defined, as all of human history has been, by all four.

The last paragraph really need no commentary.

Now, let’s get to the part I find most interesting.

  • Let me tell you what this means. First, we seek security, which is the foundation of peace and prosperity. We stand for an international order in which the rights and responsibilities of all nations and all people are upheld. Where international law and norms are enforced. Where commerce and freedom of navigation are not impeded. Where emerging powers contribute to regional security, and where disagreements are resolved peacefully. That’s the future that we seek.

    • We failed horribly here. We never held the PRC to account for its human rights abuses against its ethnic minorities. We did nothing about its island-building in the South China Sea or its aggressive actions against its neighbors’ maritime claims. The PRC now has the world’s largest navy. The US Navy has not successfully designed and built a new class of surface warship since this speech was made.

  • Now, I know that some in this region have wondered about America’s commitment to upholding these principles. So let me address this directly. As the United States puts our fiscal house in order, we are reducing our spending. And, yes, after a decade of extraordinary growth in our military budgets -- and as we definitively end the war in Iraq, and begin to wind down the war in Afghanistan -- we will make some reductions in defense spending.

    • In November 2015, U.S. national debt was $15.22 trillion. It is not $40.5 trillion. U.S. military spending as a percentage of GDP was 4.8% in 2011. By the end of the Obama presidency, it had fallen to 3.8%. By 2025, it was down to 3.1%. For 2026, it is estimated at 3.4%.

  • As we consider the future of our armed forces, we’ve begun a review that will identify our most important strategic interests and guide our defense priorities and spending over the coming decade. So here is what this region must know. As we end today’s wars, I have directed my national security team to make our presence and mission in the Asia Pacific a top priority. As a result, reductions in U.S. defense spending will not -- I repeat, will not -- come at the expense of the Asia Pacific.

    • Just look at where our military has deployed over the last decade. We still have not built additional shipyards or production facilities on the West Coast. We have shut down Red Hills. Do I need to list more?

…

  • All of our nations -- Australia, the United States -- all of our nations have a profound interest in the rise of a peaceful and prosperous China. That’s why the United States welcomes it. We’ve seen that China can be a partner from reducing tensions on the Korean Peninsula to preventing proliferation. And we’ll seek more opportunities for cooperation with Beijing, including greater communication between our militaries to promote understanding and avoid miscalculation. We will do this, even as we continue to speak candidly to Beijing about the importance of upholding international norms and respecting the universal human rights of the Chinese people.

    • How is this working out for everyone? That was the great weakness of the Obama Administration, and its echo in the Biden Administration: from Iran to the PRC, assume the best of your nation’s opponents—from Tehran to Beijing. Treat the foreign as a nuisance to be mitigated, the domestic as an enemy to be crushed.

OK. Let’s return to November of 2026. In the Trump Administration, the person who advocates for a Pacific Pivot more than anyone else, Midrats Podcast alumnus Under Secretary Elbridge Colby, is still trying to make the argument President Obama put out in 2011.

You may hold any opinion you wish about former President Barack Obama, he was an exceptional speaker and, once he got through his apology tour, almost always represented his nation well on the world stage.

h/t CB.

Leave a comment

Share

This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

View the full article

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.