Jump to content

Logo

Photo

NavHist - BOOK REVIEW – Fort Enterprize


  • Please log in to reply
No replies to this topic

#1 HG S2 (Intel Bot)

HG S2 (Intel Bot)

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 5,430 posts

Posted 19 May 2017 - 07:45 AM

Fort-Enterprize-195x300.jpgBy Kevin Emmet Foley, Hellgate Press, Ashland, OR (2016)

Reviewed by William H. White

Fort Enterprize is listed and sold as âhistorical fiction.â It is certainly fiction, but its historical claim leaves much to be desired. When a writer injects a fictitious character or several into an accurately portrayed historical context, itâs historical fiction; when a writer changes or fictionalizes real history, that becomes something else entirely. In this case, Mr. Foley has taken some marvelous naval and U.S. history and trivialized it by creating ânew eventsâ in which real characters play a role. Injecting his lead character, Presley Neville OâBannon, U.S. Marine, into completely false scenarios because ââ¦I am certain this valiant United States Marine would have wanted to be in the thick of thingsâ is irresponsible and outrageous. OâBannonâs service in the (misrepresented) march across the desert is heroic enough; his character needs no bolstering from the author.

While author Foley has offered an interesting tale of derring-do during the first Barbary Wars, his knowledge of things maritime, naval, and, yes, historical, is sadly lacking. A couple of brief examples: early in the story, Foley refers to a âfirst mateâ on a U.S. Navy warship and compounds the error by calling him a âwarrant officer.â He often refers to someone being âcourt marshalled,â as opposed to court martialed.â A competent editor should have picked this up, along with the many other âword errorsâ found throughout the text. A common error made by writers about this period, including Foley, is the use of âUSSâ relating to navy ships; that designation didnât come into usage until Teddy Roosevelt was President. Foley repeatedly refers to junior officers with the rank of âensign,â a rank that did not come into being until the Civil War. I mention these somewhat trivial offenses (the tip of the iceberg) because they annoy a knowledgeable reader and are easily avoided with a minimum amount of research. The use of vulgar language by real senior officers at that time was unheard of, but Foley brings their speech into the 21st century with some remarkably foul dialog.

Foley mentions the attack of the fire/bomb ship Intrepid in Tripoli Harbor, but changes not only the details of the event, but puts a totally different officer, Henry Wadsworth, instead of the real commander, Richard Somers, in command for no apparent reason except possibly his already proven aversion to research.

The format of the story is interesting and imaginative and, while this effort makes for an often-exciting tale of heroism and courage, mistaking it for any kind of history will lead to disappointment for an informed reader.

BuyOnAmazon.gif

White is an accomplished fictional writer of the early 19th century and member of the Foundationâs Holloway Society.

BOOK REVIEW – Fort Enterprize was published by the Naval Historical Foundation and originally appeared on Naval Historical Foundation on May 19, 2017.


View the full article




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users